https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=502091

--- Comment #20 from Gabriel Gazzán <gabcor...@gmail.com> ---
(In reply to Bernd from comment #19)

> I understand that and find it a good UX. But then a track is only created
> above the top most track. What if I wanted/needed a new track between V2 and
> V3?

In case the user wanted to create a new track between V2 and V3, the procedure
would be almost the same, just having to press Ctrl (or another modifier key)
to enable the insertion of new track between any two tracks.
As I envision it, the time where the selected clip would be dropped would be
always marked by an inverted triangle (maybe smaller than the timeline cursor
one) in the time ruler. That way, while dragging, the user will have an exact
feedback of the time in which the clips will be dropped, no matter if this is
done above all or between any two tracks.

Which rises your very valid question:
> Why would I need a modifier for this? Why not make track separation lines
> sensitive areas from the very start?

Well (and that's debatable, of course, but) the main reason I imagined the use
of a modifier key for track insertion between existent tracks, was to avoid the
timeline to become a "Xmas tree" every time the user drags a clip to a track
for other purposes.
Dragging a clip above the top-most track (or bottom-most track) is a very
specific action that I think could trigger the dashed line (or even open that
cool preview, @balooii showed us) without causing noticeable hassle or being
distracting if activated by error, but I guess, having dashed lines or mini
track previews appearing and disappearing as the mouse cursor travels over each
tracks division line could be.
So the solution to avoid that would be that, only when the user "declares an
intention" to do so (by pressing Ctrl) the said dashed lines would be shown.

Maybe there could be alternate solutions to that, and I'm totally open to them.
:)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to