issues  

Messages by Date

• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Use typed config for `ALLOW_WILDCARD_LOCATION` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Use typed config for `POLARIS_TASK_TIMEOUT_MILLIS` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Extract root Principal setup code into a common util class [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [I] Incomplete upload of artifacts to Github Release [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] NoSQL: Retain only the most recent state in metastore maintenance [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Versioned-docs: do not index old versioned docs [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Add tentative script to regenerate the Helm index [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 [PR] Add tentative script to regenerate the Helm index [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Update Gradle to 9.3.0 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Update Gradle to 9.3.0 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Update Gradle to 9.3.0 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 [PR] Update Gradle to 9.3.0 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 [PR] Test libraries for storage operations [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [I] Invalid GH page [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/23 Re: [I] Invalid GH page [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] NoSQL: Add to runtime-service [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Object storage operations [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Add doc for couple new feature flags introduced recently [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Add doc for couple new feature flags introduced recently [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Invalid GH page [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [I] Invalid GH page [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] (doc) Add doc for couple new feature flags [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (nit)Python CLI: Update max supported python version [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] (feat) Tool: Make python version configuration in Makefile [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc)Updated cli doc with new options introduced in catalog create operation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Apparenly unused "index-dependency" config in application.properties [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] (nit)Python CLI: Update max supported python version [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] chore(deps): update dependency python to 3.14 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] chore(deps): update dependency python to 3.14 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Object storage operations [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (feat) Add support for no KMS with s3-compatible backend [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] NoSQL: Add to runtime-service [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Apparenly unused "index-dependency" config in application.properties [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] NoSQL: Add maintenance service to Polaris admin tool [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [I] Incomplete upload of artifacts to Github Release [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Object storage operations [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Implement register view endpoint [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Implement register view endpoint [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] [Feature Request] [Console] Add Authorization Option via OIDC [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] [Feature Request] [Console] Add Authorization Option via OIDC [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] [POC] Replace custom token bucket with Quarkus Bucket4J extension [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] Replace custom token-bucket implementation with Guava's `RateLimiter` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] fix: gitignore .env [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] [POC] Replace custom token bucket with Quarkus Bucket4J extension [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] fix: gitignore .env [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [I] Implement register view endpoint [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Add jitpack.io repository [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Add jitpack.io repository [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] fix: gitignore .env [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] fix: gitignore .env [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Catalog Migrator: Configure Apache Maven publishing [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Add jitpack.io repository [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] Add jitpack.io repository [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 [PR] Add jitpack.io repository [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/22 Re: [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [PR] (doc) Outdated changelog [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [PR] (doc)Updated cli doc with new options introduced in catalog create [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [PR] Add support for no KMS with s3-compatible backend [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat: pass ExternalCatalog properties into federated catalogs [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat: pass ExternalCatalog properties into federated catalogs [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] deduplicate storage requests when loading views. [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] ensure sts is cached regardless of the refresh endpoint [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] ensure sts is cached regardless of the refresh endpoint [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] RELATIONAL_JDBC: Move Events to dedicated Quarkus datasource [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] RELATIONAL_JDBC: Move Events to dedicated Quarkus datasource [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(persistence): Add database schema and persistence layer for Iceberg metrics reporting (#3337) [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] core: introduce `resolvePathsOnly()` in `Resolver` and `PolarisResolutionManifest` [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(persistence): Add database schema and persistence layer for Iceberg metrics reporting (#3337) [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(persistence): Add database schema and persistence layer for Iceberg metrics reporting (#3337) [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Site: Update Slack invite [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(persistence): Add database schema and persistence layer for Iceberg metrics reporting (#3337) [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] STS inline policy includes KMS actions even when KMS is not configured [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] STS inline policy includes KMS actions even when KMS is not configured [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Make Principal Scope configurable in Console [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Make Principal Scope configurable in Console [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [D] Iceberg history log management [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Make Principal Scope configurable in Console [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [D] Iceberg Table Maintenance [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Use archive.apache.org for previous releases [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] Require approval from 2 reviewers before merging [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(metrics): Evolve PolarisMetricsReporter interface with timestamp parameter and comprehensive documentation [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured and improved default KMS permission for RO/RW [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (getting-started) Avoid latest image tags for all other images except polaris [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (feat) Add example for rustfs integration [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [I] Older Helm charts are missing in downloads.apache.org/incubator/polaris/helm-chart/ [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat: pass ExternalCatalog properties into federated catalogs [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured and improved default KMS permission for RO/RW [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured and improved default KMS permission for RO/RW [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] (fix) Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Console: Be able to configure the token URL [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [PR] feat(console): Make OAuth token URL configurable [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [I] Console: Be able to configure the token URL [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [D] Iceberg Table Maintenance [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [D] Iceberg history log management [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 [PR] Catalog Migrator: Configure Apache Maven publishing [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] chore(deps): update plugin com.gradle.develocity to v4.3.1 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/21 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] fix(deps): update dependency ch.qos.logback:logback-classic to v1.5.25 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] fix(deps): update dependency io.smallrye.config:smallrye-config-core to v3.15.1 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] chore(deps): update docker.io/adobe/s3mock docker tag to v4.11.0 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] Make Principal Scope configurable in Console [polaris-tools] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 [PR] (nit) Avoid latest image tage for all other images except polaris [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] (WIP) Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] (WIP) Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 [PR] DO-NOT-MERGE (fix) Refined AWS vs non-AWS detection for S3-compatible storage [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 [I] Management API Catalog Creation Fails with ContextNotActiveException (Quarkus CDI) in Polaris 1.1.0, 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 on K8 [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 [PR] Fixed IcebergCatalog stale FileIO after metadata refresh [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] Service: Use iterator to avoid high space complexity [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 [PR] Remove KMS policies when KMS is not configured and improved default KMS permission for RO/RW [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] [Issue 3209] Surface Intermediate Data as part of Polaris Events [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] Service: Use iterator to avoid high space complexity [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] Object storage operations [polaris] via GitHub
• 2026/01/20 Re: [PR] (feat) Add example for rustfs integration [polaris] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages