szehon-ho commented on code in PR #17318:
URL: https://github.com/apache/iceberg/pull/17318#discussion_r4160311847


##########
format/spec.md:
##########
@@ -2069,38 +2069,38 @@ Snapshot summary can include metrics fields to track 
numeric stats of the snapsh
 
 #### Metrics
 
-| Field                               | Description                            
                                                          |
-|-------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
-| **`added-data-files`**              | Number of data files added in the 
snapshot                                                       |
-| **`deleted-data-files`**            | Number of data files deleted in the 
snapshot                                                     |
-| **`total-data-files`**              | Total number of live data files in the 
snapshot                                                  |
-| **`added-delete-files`**            | Number of positional/equality delete 
files and deletion vectors added in the snapshot            |
-| **`added-equality-delete-files`**   | Number of equality delete files added 
in the snapshot                                            |
-| **`removed-equality-delete-files`** | Number of equality delete files 
removed in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`added-position-delete-files`**   | Number of position delete files added 
in the snapshot                                            |
-| **`removed-position-delete-files`** | Number of position delete files 
removed in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`added-dvs`**                     | Number of deletion vectors added in 
the snapshot                                                 |
-| **`removed-dvs`**                   | Number of deletion vectors removed in 
the snapshot                                               |
-| **`removed-delete-files`**          | Number of positional/equality delete 
files and deletion vectors removed in the snapshot          |
-| **`total-delete-files`**            | Total number of live 
positional/equality delete files and deletion vectors in the snapshot       |
-| **`added-records`**                 | Number of records added in the 
snapshot                                                          |
-| **`deleted-records`**               | Number of records deleted in the 
snapshot                                                        |
-| **`total-records`**                 | Total number of records in the 
snapshot                                                          |
-| **`added-files-size`**              | The size of files added in the 
snapshot                                                          |
-| **`removed-files-size`**            | The size of files removed in the 
snapshot                                                        |
-| **`total-files-size`**              | Total size of live files in the 
snapshot                                                         |
-| **`added-position-deletes`**        | Number of position delete records 
added in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`removed-position-deletes`**      | Number of position delete records 
removed in the snapshot                                        |
-| **`total-position-deletes`**        | Total number of position delete 
records in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`added-equality-deletes`**        | Number of equality delete records 
added in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`removed-equality-deletes`**      | Number of equality delete records 
removed in the snapshot                                        |
-| **`total-equality-deletes`**        | Total number of equality delete 
records in the snapshot                                          |
-| **`deleted-duplicate-files`**       | Number of duplicate files deleted 
(duplicates are files recorded more than once in the manifest) |
-| **`changed-partition-count`**       | Number of partitions with files added 
or removed in the snapshot                                 |
-| **`manifests-created`**             | Number of manifest files created in 
the snapshot                                                 |
-| **`manifests-kept`**                | Number of manifest files kept in the 
snapshot                                                    |
-| **`manifests-replaced`**            | Number of manifest files replaced in 
the snapshot                                                |
-| **`entries-processed`**             | Number of manifest entries processed 
in the snapshot                                             |
+| Field                               | Description                            
                                                                      |
+|-------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
+| **`added-data-files`**              | Number of data files added in the 
snapshot                                                                   |
+| **`deleted-data-files`**            | Number of data files deleted in the 
snapshot                                                                 |
+| **`total-data-files`**              | Total number of live data files in the 
snapshot                                                              |
+| **`added-delete-files`**            | Number of positional/equality delete 
files and deletion vectors added in the snapshot                        |
+| **`added-equality-delete-files`**   | Number of equality delete files added 
in the snapshot                                                        |
+| **`removed-equality-delete-files`** | Number of equality delete files 
removed in the snapshot                                                      |
+| **`added-position-delete-files`**   | Number of position delete files added 
in the snapshot                                                        |
+| **`removed-position-delete-files`** | Number of position delete files 
removed in the snapshot                                                      |
+| **`added-dvs`**                     | Number of deletion vectors added in 
the snapshot                                                             |
+| **`removed-dvs`**                   | Number of deletion vectors removed in 
the snapshot                                                           |
+| **`removed-delete-files`**          | Number of positional/equality delete 
files and deletion vectors removed in the snapshot                      |
+| **`total-delete-files`**            | Total number of live 
positional/equality delete files and deletion vectors in the snapshot           
        |
+| **`added-records`**                 | Number of records added in the 
snapshot                                                                      |
+| **`deleted-records`**               | Number of records deleted in the 
snapshot                                                                    |
+| **`total-records`**                 | Total number of records in the 
snapshot (does not account for position/equality deletes or deletion vectors) |

Review Comment:
   Could we keep “in live data files” here? It makes explicit that removed 
files are excluded, while deleted rows still present in live files count toward 
the total.
   
   Suggested wording:
   > Total number of records in live data files in the snapshot, before 
applying position deletes, equality deletes, or deletion vectors.



-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to