issues  

Messages by Date

• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] refactor: harden FileCleanupStrategy with retry and parallel deletes [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] refactor: harden FileCleanupStrategy with retry and parallel deletes [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] refactor: harden FileCleanupStrategy with retry and parallel deletes [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] API, Spark 4.1: Add ignore_missing_files to snapshot procedure [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Parquet: Avoid intermediate BigInteger in int and long decimal readers [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] API, Spark 4.1: Add ignore_missing_files to snapshot procedure [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add EntryStatus.MODIFIED and TrackingBuilder status derivation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add KLL Datasketch as standard blob types to puffin file [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add KLL Datasketch as standard blob types to puffin file [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add KLL Datasketch as standard blob types to puffin file [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add writer_format_version field to TrackedFile [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] feat(catalog): Cloud storage backend support for hadoop [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] chore: disable installing googletest libs [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] refactor!(writer): borrow TableMetadata in DefaultLocationGenerator::new [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] fix(transforms): day transform result type is date, not int [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] [Spec] table properties needs a spec [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(spec): Fix incorrect totals when previous is omitted or invalid [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] fix: Assign UUID when creating table metadata [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Basic fields and schemas for column files [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] [SPEC] Add finer grained read restrictions as part of loadTable [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add writer_format_version field to TrackedFile [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Rebuild REST cached tables with current context [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Backport source fetcher thread leak fix to v1.20 and v2.0 (#16545) [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] Flink: Backport source fetcher thread leak fix to v1.20 and v2.0 (#16545) [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Kafka Connect: Follow-up identifier field validations and error contract alignment [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Handle ExceptionInInitializerError & NoClassDefFoundError invoke-time failures in DynMethods callers [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(spec): Fix incorrect totals when previous is omitted or invalid [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(encryption) [7/N] Read encrypted manifest list [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(spec): Fix incorrect totals when previous is omitted or invalid [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(encryption) [7/N] Read encrypted manifest list [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Handle ExceptionInInitializerError & NoClassDefFoundError invoke-time failures in DynMethods callers [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Metadata stop to be written after random period of time. Commit failed, will try again next cycle. [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(s3tables): add TableNotFound error handling [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [I] Core: Expose commit retry exhaustion reason in failure messages [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(s3tables): add TableNotFound error handling [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(spec): Fix incorrect totals when previous is omitted or invalid [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Feature/oauth refresh plus 401 retry [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(io/s3): support connect timeout property [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(io/s3): support connect timeout property [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] Feature/oauth refresh plus 401 retry [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [I] Windows ARM64 wheel support [iceberg-python] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(io/s3): support connect timeout property [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Fix equality deletes failing for nested field identifiers. [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Cannot use IcebergCatalogProvider with a Glue catalog that contains mixed types of tables [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(catalog): Only list iceberg tables for Glue [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] CLI: Expose REST catalog page size as a flag [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(cli): expose REST catalog page size as --page-size flag [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add KLL Datasketch as standard blob types to puffin file [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(transaction): Add SnapshotValidator [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] perf(table): dedupe shared manifest reads in orphan cleanup [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Orphan cleanup reads shared manifests redundantly — O(snapshots × manifests) I/O [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Allow custom writer factory in DynamicIcebergSink [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(encryption) [7/N] Read encrypted manifest list [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK coverage for reader default values [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: SQL: Add variant avro dynamic record generator [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK coverage for reader default values [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Parquet: Fix initial-default rows dropped when filtering on the defaulted column [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Support for projecting metadata columns _pos, _spec_id, and _partition in table scan [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: implement wakeup method to fix thread/memory leak [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: implement wakeup method to fix thread/memory leak [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Flink: Source fetcher threads leak when Iceberg reader is cancelled [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Add writer_format_version field to TrackedFile [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] perf(schema-update): use Set<Integer> for deletes to get O(1) contains() lookups [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK for Encrypt in FileFormat API [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Allow custom writer factory in DynamicIcebergSink [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK coverage for reader default values [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Add TCK coverage for reader default values [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Data: Fix equality deletes failing for nested field identifiers. [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] Data: Skip equality-delete filter when there are no equality deletes [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] fix: avoid stale gh run watch in RC release script [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] chore: disable installing googletest libs [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [I] REST Catalog: expose a staged create-or-replace transaction primitive for non-Java clients [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Basic fields and schemas for column files [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Core: Adjust calculations for reserved field IDs [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(table): WKB encoding + GeoArrow conversion for geometry/geography [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] feat(compaction): add MaxFilesToRewrite option [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(storage-opendal): add TimeoutLayer inside RetryLayer to bound hangs [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(storage-opendal): add TimeoutLayer inside RetryLayer to bound hangs [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix: accept UTC timestamps in parquet writer [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Flink: Update Flink release notes for 1.11.0 release [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(rest): add scan plan endpoints to REST catalog client [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(hive): vendor Hive 3.1 metastore + fb303 Thrift IDL [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] feat(hive): vendor Hive 3.1 metastore + fb303 Thrift IDL [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] build: install generated version header [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [I] Update Table Error: UPDATE TABLE is not supported temporarily. [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] Spark tests cache rewrite input [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] AWS: Honor init-creation-stacktrace in S3 input and output streams [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] build: install generated version header [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 Re: [PR] fix(spec): Fix incorrect totals when previous is omitted or invalid [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/09 [PR] AWS: Optimize Iceberg-to-Glue schema type conversion [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] Core: Backport DV encryption metadata preservation to 1.10.x [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Adjust calculations for reserved field IDs [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Adjust calculations for reserved field IDs [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] Unsupported S3 Properties [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Adjust calculations for reserved field IDs [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] feat: add DeleteFiles update API [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] feat(catalog): Cloud storage backend support for hadoop [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] Core: Extend org.apache.iceberg.hadoop.Configurable in HadoopConfigurable [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] Hive: Fix conversion failure for nested VARIANT and reduce type-string allocations [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] implement cache policy [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [Spec] table properties needs a spec [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Fix RESTMetricsReporter.report() blocking the calling thread [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [Spec] table properties needs a spec [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [I] [Spec] table properties needs a spec [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Basic fields and schemas for column files [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Basic fields and schemas for column files [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Avoid implementing HadoopConfigurable in ResolvingFileIO [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Preserve DV encryption metadata in merges [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Core: Basic fields and schemas for column files [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] Flink: Avoid redundant java.time allocations in ORC timestamp writers [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Flink: Add ConvertEqualityDeletes maintenance task [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] Core: Avoid implementing HadoopConfigurable in ResolvingFileIO [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] ORC, Flink: Avoid redundant java.time allocations when reading ORC timestamps [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(rest): add scan plan endpoints to REST catalog client [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Docs: Clarify Spark `spark.sql.adaptive.advisoryPartitionSizeInBytes` [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 [PR] feat: implement merge multiple DVs [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] fix(spec): validate schema types by format version [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(table): WKB encoding + GeoArrow conversion for geometry/geography [iceberg-go] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Kafka Connect: recover from metadata commit stall after Kafka cluster recreation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] parquet: Allow setting parquet rowgroup row count limit [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] feat(arrow): resolve S3-compatible schemes in ArrowFileSystemFileIO [iceberg-cpp] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] parquet: Allow setting parquet rowgroup row count limit [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [Feature] Add Support for Distributed Write [iceberg-python] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] PyArrowFile class is not compatible with ABFS uri syntax [iceberg-python] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] rest catalog does not support pagination [iceberg-python] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [Feat] Add rewrite_table_path Spark procedure to support table replication [iceberg-python] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Support Filter Pushdown in Spark Structured Streaming [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [epic] add all features of the IRC spec to the IRC reference implementation [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Repro REST vs non-REST concurrent replace behaviour [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] [KAFKA CONNECT] ForbiddenException: Forbidden: Invalid Token [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Aliyun, Dell: Handle EOF in OSS and ECS InputStream read() variants [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] Add Tags field to Iceberg V4 [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] Observing the extra forward `/ ` after the `/data/ `in the s3 after ingesting the data to non-partitioned iceberg [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Add unknown datatype support [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] Add comprehensive error handling system for REST catalog [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [I] Add support for null values in `Datum` [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Spark: Fix first row ID carry over for manifest rewrite [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Mumbling: Add draft Mumbling Bitmap spec [iceberg] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] fix(s3tables): add TableNotFound error handling [iceberg-rust] via GitHub
• 2026/06/08 Re: [PR] Phase3 rowdelta delete conflicts [iceberg-rust] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages