All, I want to start a discussion about our add-on files practice and try to improve it.
I agree it is reasonable to install bash completions unconditionally, because bash is part of the base requirement for Gentoo. However, I do not agree that we should continue installing add-on files for everything under the sun unconditionally. I believe, back in the day we started this practice, portage did not support --newuse or --changed-use, so there was no way to only update packages that had changed or new use flags. In that situation, I understand why we installed all of these add-on files unconditionally and told users to use INSTALL_MASK if they wanted them not to be on their systems. However, I feel that we should update our practice now since we have these features available to us and to our users. In my previous thread about zsh, it was suggested that I could use the zsh-completion use flag to control zsh-completion installation, and not rdepend on zsh. This is now how pybugz is set up. The suggestion was made because zsh is not common, so let's try to define what common means to get an idea of when use flags can be used like this. I think the most fair/objective way to define whether something is common is whether or not it is part of the base requirement, like bash, or whether it is the default provided by a virtual. In either of those cases, I would say it makes sense to install add-on files that the program might use unconditionally. Thoughts? William
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
