We have had a talk about yEd on #gentoo-dev which is worth attaching
here:

  <@ulm> aidecoe: I suspect that yEd is in violation of the GPL :/
  <@ulm> their package zip file includes JavaHelp classes but no source code 
for them
  <@ulm> and I also don't see it at their site
  <@ulm> neither do they include the GPL license text
  <@aidecoe> ulm: they provide links in their license
  <@ulm> that's not enough
  <@ulm> read the GPL ;)
  <@aidecoe> yes, i have read
  <@aidecoe> some time ago
  <@ulm> what's probably worse, they pack that GPLed software into their jar
  <@ulm> and in clause 1 of the yed license they forbid to unjar it
  <@aidecoe> yes, that's not fair
  <@ulm> and in clause 6 they forbid distribution
  <@ulm> I'm pretty sure that this contradicts the GPL
  <@ulm> aidecoe: that would be another reason for mirror restriction ;)
  <@aidecoe> ulm: i'll mail them about it


I have just sent nice e-mail to yWorks about this.


-- 
Amadeusz Żołnowski

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to