On 2026/11/05 20:31:10 larry mccay via general wrote:

> The community building part, while important for TLP success, shouldn't be
> a trap that extends incubation, IMO.
> If a podling is demonstrating the ability to make decisions properly and
> to get releases out in response to need and/or project growth then
> shouldn't have to prove much more in order to become TLP.
> Perhaps community building/health isn't a hard gate even today but the
> messaging needs to be more clear.

Big +1 to that. I have heard from multiple companies that they are unwilling - 
or even forbidden by policy - to get involve in projects that are in the 
Incubator, because why would they waste time and money engaging with a project 
that might not graduate? (Yes, this is a frustrating attitude, and, yes, I ague 
against it, but it remains a fact, and so staying in the incubator *reduces* 
the ability to grow a community in some case.)

FWIW, The counterexample to that attitude can be seen in Russel's excellent 
keynote at Community Over Code last month -- 
https://youtu.be/3HWBqiyllbk?si=1kO1LWVznMXpgiKx -- and I want every 
engineering manager in the world to watch that.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to