Nice optimisation indeed. Just wondering if we can make it even more optimized and simpler (also for implementation in ATR). We could start both votes in parallel - without even getting the three +1s from PPM -C. The whole vote passes only when both votes pass.
Both approaches have the same "invalidation" edge case as waiting for three +1s from PPMC and two or fewer -1s. With the proposed scheme, another -1 cast by PPMC could invalidate both votes. Therefore, we must handle the case where there are enough votes in the second phase but not enough in PPMC voting. Negative effect is that you might start voting without knowing if there are enough votes from PPMC. However, if the purpose of the 72 hours is to make people aware that the vote is in progress and give them a chance to vote "no," this is also fulfilled if both votes start simultaneously. Furthermore, accounting and implementation are faster, and the "vote ends" period is more predictable. J. On Sat, Oct 17, 2026 at 5:43 AM Jean-Baptiste Onofré <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Dave > > Thanks for the update. Fully agree about the approach. > > Regards > JB > > On Fri, Oct 16, 2026 at 7:22 PM Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Recently the IPMC has voted to allow overlapping votes on podling > > releases. No set point was determined for allowing this, just that the > vote > > periods could overlap. Meanwhile the new Apache Trusted Releases platform > > (ATR) is ready for a complete beta test at releases.apache.org. > > > > ATR has implemented the standard two phase vote for podlings. > > > > We want to implement the overlapping vote pattern, but would like to > > propose some structure around when the second phase vote can occur. > > > > Our proposal is that the second phase be allowed to proceed as soon as > > first phase has enough PPMC (including Mentor) Votes to pass even if just > > in the first few hours. > > > > For example, if there were 3 +1 from PPMC members and two or fewer -1 > then > > the general@incubator vote will be started. > > > > I’ll leave this for LAZY CONSENSUS in seven days if there is no > objection. > > Happy to discuss. > > > > Best, > > Dave > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > > > >
