Hi Justin,

Thank you for taking another careful look at RC2, and for keeping us
honest on the IP side. It's really helpful for a first release.

Good news on the ICLAs: both contributors now have one on file.

- UncertaintyDeterminesYou4ndMe is Jiaxiong Liu. The PPMC voted him in
  as a committer on 2026-09-10, and the Secretary confirmed his ICLA on
  2026-09-24. His Apache account hasn't been created yet, which is
  probably why it didn't turn up. I've asked the mentors to request it.
- Mingqwqqaq has also filed an ICLA with the Secretary.

For completeness, the other two contributors in the #3268 table are
also covered. zhiiw is Zhiyi Wang, a PPMC member with an ICLA on file.
The Deep Research code by ACMerJuyu was removed before RC2, leaving six
generic lines, as noted in the vote email.

On the nightlies, thanks for flagging this again. After talking it over
with the mentors, my understanding is that developer builds are fine as
long as they aren't promoted to the general public. I removed the
Nightly links from the website and README in [1]. The npm nightly
README already includes DISCLAIMER-WIP in full. You're right that the
GitHub prerelease pages didn't show it, and [2] adds it there.

If this addresses your concerns, I'd be grateful if you could take
another look at your vote. Please let me know if anything else is
missing.

Best,
Yuhan Lei
Apache ID: astrohan

[1] https://github.com/apache/maka/pull/5544
[2] https://github.com/apache/maka/pull/5861

On 2026-09-29 05:32 UTC Justin Mclean wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> -1 (binding), but see below
> 
> I checked:
>    • incubating in name
>    • signature and hash are good
>    • DISCLAIMER-WIP exists
>    • LICENSE and NOTICE are fine
>    • no unexpected binary files
>    • all source files have ASF headers one
> 
> However, the issue I raised on RC1 is still there. Issue #3268 shows that 36% 
> of the surviving lines were written before the repository had any license, 
> and two of the larger contributors from that period (27,449 lines) have no 
> ICLA on file that I can find. UncertaintyDeterminesYou4ndMe (27,449 lines) 
> have no ICLA on file that I can find, but mapping GitHub names is difficult. 
> I notice that it is claimed in that issue, "The SGA is an incubation setup 
> item, not a release item” and similar AI-generated statements; this is not 
> correct. The release policy is clear: we can’t release stuff we don't have 
> permission to.[2].
> 
> If that ICLA is in place, or we have an SGA covering them, or the mentor's 
> record on some other basis, that's fine, and I withdraw my -1 vote. I notice 
> they are still active in the project; has anyone asked them for an ICLA?
> 
> The nightly builds are also still public. There are 30 "Maka Desktop Nightly" 
> GitHub prereleases, the latest from yesterday, and npm maka-agent has a 
> nightly tag pointing at 0.2.0-dev.62. None of them has the incubation 
> disclaimer. This doesn't affect the source release, but it contradicts 
> release policy [1] and needs to be sorted out.
> 
> Kind regards,
> Justin
> 
> 1. https://www.apache.org/legal/release-policy.html#publication
> 2. https://www.apache.org/legal/release-policy.html#licensing
> 
> 
> 
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
> For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
> 
> 

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to