Thanks for your participation! I'm closing and concluding this vote now.

Here is my +1 binding vote

> My hesitation is that I would have preferred to have the podling explicitly 
> state:
>
> That this is a concurrent PPMC/IPMC vote
> The previous successful IPMC vote(s)
> The reason for the deviation from the standard PPMC then IPMC vote

If you are acting as a mentor, you may suggest that the PPMC follow
this pattern. Once we have some real-world practice, we can add those
examples to the release guidelines page, like the ones linked now, to
show how a concurrent vote should run.

Best,
tison.

Craig Russell <[email protected]> 于2026年9月10日周四 08:26写道:
>
> Officially, +0 clr IPMC
>
> My hesitation is that I would have preferred to have the podling explicitly 
> state:
>
> That this is a concurrent PPMC/IPMC vote
> The previous successful IPMC vote(s)
> The reason for the deviation from the standard PPMC then IPMC vote
>
> Craig
>
> > On Sep 6, 2026, at 21:08, tison <[email protected]> wrote:
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > Here is a vote to change the Incubator Guidelines on [1] to explicitly
> > permit concurrent PPMC and IPMC votes for release.
> >
> > [1] https://incubator.apache.org/policy/incubation.html#releases
> >
> > The rendered version can be found at [2], of commit
> > 56e442484462dcd16d3f3bdd75ecded0969cb719 [3]
> >
> > [2] https://github.com/apache/incubator/pull/145
> > [3]
> > https://github.com/apache/incubator/blob/56e442484462dcd16d3f3bdd75ecded0969cb719/pages/policy/incubation.ad
> >
> > Please review the proposed content and vote accordingly.
> >
> > [ ] +1 Change the Incubator Guidelines as proposed
> > [ ] +0 No opinion.
> > [ ] -1 Do not approve. Please explain why.
> >
> > Below is a copy of the frozen version (trivial markers trimmed).
> >
> > [CONTENT START]
> >
> > Releases
> >
> > See the guidelines for Podling releases for good practices for making
> > releases. The Podling can make non-ASF releases while incubating as long as
> > it is moving towards making ASF releases.
> >
> > During incubation, PPMC members learn how to govern an ASF project. A PPMC
> > operates like a PMC but reports to the Incubator PMC rather than to the ASF
> > Board. The PPMC release vote ensures that the Podling community
> > participates in producing and reviewing ASF releases. Podlings MUST NOT
> > perform any ASF releases of software without the approval of the Incubator
> > PMC. Because the PPMC cannot make formal decisions on behalf of the ASF,
> > the Incubator PMC provides the binding approval required for a Podling
> > release to become an ASF release.
> >
> > When a Podling proposes an ASF release, it MUST hold a vote on its public
> > dev list to seek endorsement from the PPMC and MUST request approval from
> > the Incubator PMC on the Incubator's general list. The PPMC vote and the
> > Incubator PMC vote MAY be conducted sequentially or, at the Podling's
> > discretion, concurrently. The timing and conduct of the votes MUST follow
> > the applicable requirements of the Apache Voting Process and the ASF
> > Release Policy.
> >
> > The proposed release is approved only when both of the following
> > requirements have been satisfied:
> >
> > - At least three PPMC members have voted +1, and there are more +1 than -1
> > votes from PPMC members.
> > - At least three Incubator PMC members have cast binding +1 votes, and
> > there are more binding +1 than binding -1 votes.
> >
> > Only votes from Incubator PMC members are binding for ASF release approval.
> >
> > Below are examples of the two kinds of release vote requests:
> >
> > - Post to the Podling dev list calling the PPMC vote.
> > - Post to the Incubator's general list requesting approval from the
> > Incubator PMC.
> >
> > Once both voting requirements have been satisfied, the Podling MAY make the
> > release available to the public under these conditions:
> >
> > - The release archive(s) MUST include the word "incubating" in the filename.
> > - The release archive(s) MUST contain a disclaimer (see above), which
> > SHOULD be placed in a DISCLAIMER or DISCLAIMER-WIP file.
> >
> > Releases for the Podling MUST be distributed through
> > http://www.apache.org/dist/incubator/Podling. The Podling MAY choose to
> > distribute approved releases through other channels by following the link:
> > https://incubator.apache.org/guides/distribution.html[guidelines here].
> >
> > [CONTENT END]
> >
> > Best,
> > tison.
>
> Craig L Russell
> [email protected]
>

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to