Hi,

Automation cannot solve this problem; it only solves part of it. We have RAT, 
and most projects run it as part of their build.

I've been reviewing incubator releases for well over a decade, and the issues I 
raise are not ones RAT would have caught. A recent candidate used HawkEye, the 
PPMC voted +1 and found no issues, and the IPMC voted -1 because of valid 
issues.

Header checks and dependency scans are good at what they cover. They don't tell 
you whether a bundled dependency's license is compatible, whether NOTICE says 
the right thing, or whether a file with a correct-looking header is genuinely 
under that license. A release can pass all of them and still ship GPL-licensed 
code, this has happened more than once.

Tools narrow down what a reviewer has to look at, but they don't remove the 
reviewer, and we cannot 100% automate this.

Kind regards,
Justin
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to