Hi Justin, Thanks for your input!
> There is some overlap with some files with [1]; this is concerning as these files are under a GPL license. Would you happen to know who has copied from whom here? If ASF files have been re-licensed under the GPL license, what is the PMC doing about this? What is the relationship, if any, between this company and the PMC? We just checked their repo and found the PR[1] which added Celeborn's code in their repo. We got in touch with them and they told us that the code was deleted a month ago. I also checked their release[2] and didn't find Celeborn's code in their source ball. So I guess this is no longer a problem? [1] https://github.com/alldatacenter/alldata/pull/415 [2] https://github.com/alldatacenter/alldata/releases Thanks, Keyong Zhou Justin Mclean <jus...@classsoftware.com> 于2023年12月27日周三 15:00写道： > Hi, > > Sorry, but it is -1 (binding) for now. Clearing up some of the issues > below may mean that I change my vote. > > I checked > - incubating in artifact name > - signatures and hashes are correct > - LICENSE mentions 1 3rd party file from Guava; however, the NOTICE lists > both Apache Spark and Apache Flink, so I think other files may have been > copied into the code base, and LICENSE is missing information or the NOTICE > is incorrect. > - There is some overlap with some files with [1]; this is concerning as > these files are under a GPL license. Would you happen to know who has > copied from whom here? If ASF files have been re-licensed under the GPL > license, what is the PMC doing about this? What is the relationship, if > any, between this company and the PMC? > - This file [2] seems to have been copied from Kyuubi? > - No unexpected binary files > - All files have correct source headers > - I didn't compile from the source > > Kind Regards, > Justin > > 1. https://github.com/alldatacenter/alldata > 2. /dev/checkout_pr.sh > >
