Hi,

> According to whismy page of Weex, there are 23 committer(including PPMC
> member) of Weex.

I’m a little confused the email says " 11 PPMC members, 8 committers”, 11+8 == 
19 where have the extras come from? (3 mentors?)

You also didn’t answer how many PMC members you have added during incubation

 I also notice 2 of your PPMC are not signed up to your price list is it 
expected that these be on the initial list of PMC members?

> Considering the fact that there are around 200
> contributors, 10% of them are committers, I think this is a normal
> situation(maybe other projects have higher percent of committers?), IMO.
> 
> A quick search showed that there is also some branding/trademark issues
>> with these pages:
>> 
> 
> I can explain them one by, if this is needed.

The project needs to go those these one by one (and the other links not 
mentioned) and decide:
1. Would users be confused by this page? Would they think it is related or part 
of the Apache Weex project?
2. Are they using the Weex branding correctly? If not what needs to be done to 
fix this?

I see by you reply some work needs to be done here and I suggest you also read 
those branding and trademark links.

As this point I don’t think the project is ready to graduate, what do the 
mentors think?

Thanks,
Justin
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org

Reply via email to