On 6/7/07, William A. Rowe, Jr. <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
All very good suggestions. ant elder wrote: > > How about changing it so; > > (1) incubator-private is notified that discussion of a new committer is > starting on the poddling's private list so IPMCers can participate in that > discussion; > > (2) when the actual vote happens the incubator is notified again so they > can > participate on the poddlings mailing list (ie not voting /discussing on > incubator-private where the poddling PPMC can't see whats going on); > > (3) the IPMC peoples votes are done by lazy consensus so as long as there > are enough poddling PPMC votes the vote passes whether or not there are 3 > binding IPMC votes > > (4) the same (1) (2) (3) for a new PPMC member (maybe (3) should be dropped > for a new PPMC member?) All around +1 - this is a really sane way to handle things. Pre-notifying [EMAIL PROTECTED] gives them their chance to raise issues while the vote is still going on, and 3 will usually be nothing but an ack.
sounds very reasonable to me as well - robert
