https://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=115924
--- Comment #2 from Andrew Pinski <pinskia at gcc dot gnu.org> --- Note clang also falls over for 3 additions and swapping the order of the addition just slightly. ``` #include <stdint.h> int32_t f(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return ((i2 >> 17) + (aa >> 17) + (aa1 >> 17)) << 17; } int32_t fa(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return ((i2 >> 17) + (aa1 >> 17) + (aa >> 17)) << 17; } int32_t f2(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return ((((i2 & -(1 << 17)) + aa) & -(1 << 17)) + aa1) & -(1 << 17); } int32_t f2a(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return ((((i2 & -(1 << 17)) + aa1) & -(1 << 17)) + aa) & -(1 << 17); } bool f3a(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return f(i2, aa, aa1) == fa(i2, aa, aa1); } bool f3(int32_t i2, int32_t aa, int32_t aa1) { return f(i2, aa, aa1) == f2a(i2, aa, aa1); } ``` So the question becomes which is more Canonical rather than anything else.