https://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=60933

--- Comment #11 from Leif Leonhardy <bugfeed at online dot de> ---
(In reply to Jonathan Wakely from comment #2)
> We've had situations in the past where the minimum suggested versions work
> and the latest versions prevented GCC from building.
Well, in the past... ;-)


> The suggested versions
> are known to work and have been thoroughly tested, which might not be true
> of the latest versions.
Sure.

But note that this is not (or no longer) true for at least GMP 4.3.2, assuming
"works" includes "the library's test suite passes [when compiled] with GCC".  

I.e., GMP 4.3.2's test suite contains a subtle bug (fixed long ago, in all
later versions) that will cause a single test (t-scan) to fail when compiled
with GCC 4.8.0 and any later version; it only incidentally doesn't show up with
earlier ones.

While the bug doesn't affect the library code or GCC itself, it is annoying to
users building GCC as well, as most won't know until they report it to
gmp-bugs, which happens pretty often.  (In fact, the error message of course
asks them to do so.  And people are encouraged to run 'make check'.)

Reply via email to