On Fri, 28 Mar 2008, Volker Reichelt wrote: > Hi Joseph, > > on March 15 you changed to priority of PR 35435 and PR 35441 to P4. > IMHO this is not in line with our current policy: > > * PR 35435 is not an error-recovery bug (i.e. we don't issue a valid > error message before the ICE). So this should rather be P2, I think. > * PR 35441 is a diagnostic bug, in which completely garbled diagnostics > are emitted. This is a user-visible regression. Richard Guenther > changed the related bugs PR 35442 and 35443 to P2, which I think is > the right setting. > > Would you mind changing the priorities? Or explain why P4 is the correct > setting after all?
I made a judgement of how significant I felt the bugs were (which includes questions of how likely they are to affect users). If you think continued presence of these bugs in Stage 3 should delay moving to regression-only mode for 4.4 (which is what the choice of P2 or P4 is about), feel free to set them back to P3 for another RM to look at them. -- Joseph S. Myers [EMAIL PROTECTED]
