Regarding performance of: lib/libc/net/nsdispatch.c
When used from: lib/libc/net/getgrent.c (called by initgroups())
I don't normally post here but I wanted to get some feed back on a performance
issue that I spotted. I run a large number of high-volume web hosting servers
and noticed on some of the servers a severe decrease in Apache's performance
when the /etc/group file is large (over 100,000 entries in a group file as it
is combined across servers).
I did a trace and found the following operation:
stat("/etc/nsswitch.conf", {st_mode=052, st_size=4503681233059861, ...}) = 0
repeating as many times as there is groups in the group file. I narrowed the
problem down to where apache calls "initgroups()" before forking each process
(nothing wrong here). And init groups goes through every entry in the group
file using getgrent(), which in turn calls nsdispatch and which for every
single call does "stat" on "/etc/nsswitch.conf" to see if it changed.
This issue impacts different servers differently, on most of the SCSI servers
this delays apache startup my maybe a minute, however, on a Dell SATA raid the
"stat" command was significantly slower and caused everything to come to a halt
for several minuted every time apache starts.
In my opinion this is a very significant performance issue when working with
large servers. Most programs, including apache, will call "initgroups()" for
every time they fork, and it the group file is large this means as many "stat"
requests on the file system as there are entries in the group file for every
single fork() that the server does.
For myself I just made it never test "stat" on "/etc/nsswitch.conf" after the
first time since I know that file is never modified. However, a better solution
would be to somehow let nsdispatch know that it is being ran in batch mode and
should not keep testing if the file has changed. This would effect both
"getgrent" and "getpwent".
_______________________________________________
[email protected] mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-performance
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[email protected]"
