Hi Fabian, thanks for pointing out the thing with the disclaimer. I added the necessary remote resources so they will be included. How do we continue, should we restart the vote completely (with 72h)? Or is it enough I re-upload and you check again?
Rest of the comments below: 2013/3/25 Fabian Christ <[email protected]> > > The KEYS are okay but could be placed at a location like > http://marmotta.incubator.apache.org/KEYS They will :) > > > Checking ./apache-marmotta-3.0.0-incubating-src.zip > > LICENSE & NOTICE: "software based on Sgvizler license under a > MIT-style license" in NOTICE but > "Sgvizler Javascript library, which is available under a "MIT" > license" in LICENSE. Is there a difference? Not a problem for the > release. > Fixed. > > "data based on JSON-LD Test Suite licensed under CC0 License" in > NOTICE but there is no info in LICENSE - what is CC0? Fix in future > releases. > Creative Commons 0 (basically public domain). http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ > Checking > ./apache-marmotta-3.0.0-incubating-webapp.zip > LICENSE & NOTICE: "H2 Database Engine under The H2 License, Version > 1.0" in NOTICE but in LICENSE there is no "H2 License". In LICENSE it > says "is dual licensed and available > under a modified version of the MPL 1.1 (Mozilla Public License) or > under the (unmodified) EPL 1.0 (Eclipse Public License)". You do not > include a copy of this modified versions. I am really not an expert > but there might be people who would argue that you need to include a > copy of such licenses in LICENSE. My understanding of the ASF policies > is that you should include copies of the license not just pointers. > People need to be able to verify the licenses without the need to > follow pointers to websites which may change. In doubt I would include > the license text. > There is no real doubt here. I copied the NOTICE from the webpage, where they say it is sufficient. I anyways appended it to the LICENSE of the webapp and installer distributions. > > Checking > ./apache-marmotta-3.0.0-incubating-installer.zip > marmotta-installer-3.0.0-incubating.jar/META-INF: Missing LICENSE, > NOTICE, DISCLAIMER > marmotta.war: Missing DISCLAIMER > > Checking > ./apache-marmotta-3.0.0-incubating-ldpath.zip > NOTICE has a list of included libs but the LICENSE does not list all > of them -> missing pointers to LICENSES > > ldpath-3.0.0-incubating.jar/META-INF : Missing LICENSE, NOTICE, DISCLAIMER > This is built by the onejar application. The LICENSE, NOTICE, and DISCLAIMER should be in all the jar files the super-jar contains. I'll check if there is a way to also include these files in the superjar. Greetings, Sebastian
