On Fri, Dec 2, 2016 at 12:27 AM, Mark Bretl <mbr...@apache.org> wrote: > John, Redirects are in place for the incubator website once hosting is > moved. > > Anthony, > > Lots of questions and I think have most of the answers... > > - Status of items in [1]: > -- All items are completed except for the remaining INFRA transition items. > -- Our reporting schedule after the initial three months is February, May, > August, November. > -- Once the private mail list has been confirmed as migrated, then all > non-PMC members will be removed from the list if they have not been already > - Geode Committer List [2]: It is correct as it was submitted by the > resolution (as only PMC members were defined), however, yes I do agree that > even though people were not added to the PMC they should have retained > committer status. > - Common Tasks [3]: I already created INFRA-12938 as the Common Task > ticket. I added those items from your list which I did not have to that > ticket. > -- Note: I do not see a Geode Sonar project on https://analysis.apache.org, > so we will have to request one later. > > How would people like to handle re-adding the initial committers? Should it > be done on an as-needed basis? However, I hope we would not need to vote > them into committers again for Geode. > > Does anyone have any history or experience with this issue?
Committers and PMCs are two completely different things. ASF only concerns itself with the PMC composition -- the rest it up to your project to define. Theoretically you could have a re-qualification for committers, but my recommendation will simply be to bulk add all of the existing ones to the LDAP group. Thanks, Roman.
