Thanks to everyone who reviewed and voted.

Vote summary:

+1 binding:
- Dianjin Wang
- Alwin Tang
- Greg Spiegelberg
- Jianghua Yang
- Andrey Borodin

-1 binding:
- Ed Espino (RM) — due to the following ASF compliance and build issues:
  - Trademark issue: The source release includes user-visible filenames
containing the Greenplum trademark. Specifically, greenplum_path.sh and
generate-greenplum-path.sh should be renamed for ASF trademark compliance.
  - Build issue: When building with the --enable-pax option, the build
fails if the protobuf development environment is not present. This is not
currently detected by the configure script.
  - Version string issue: The internal version string currently includes
"-rc1", which should not be present in the release metadata or runtime
output. That suffix is only appropriate in the artifact filename and Git
tag.

+1 non-binding:
- TomShawn

Result: RC1 is rejected. A new release candidate (RC2) will follow after
addressing the identified issues.

-=Ed Espino

Reply via email to