And, it's done! All reftest failures classified. Permalink to current revision: https://gist.github.com/Manishearth/086118c940ff86a6cfc573f53c508279/a181e327a4e2d83d75e28862d1fc01e121923bff
Bear in mind that the try run this is based on is a few days old so some of the things there may be fixed in master. I've been making drive-by patches for many of the things I come across. I'll soon do a separate analysis of the HasAuthorSpecifiedRules stuff to see what's still failing since Matt's patches have landed. There are 913 tests marked as HasAuthorSpecified in that file, and Matt's patches fixed 530, so we still have some input widget bugs floating around. I will also be removing now-passing tests if I see them, but don't rely on that being true. I don't intend to put too much time into maintaining this list; the main point was to get an idea of what needs to be fixed. I will try to investigate things which still fail when their corresponding bug lands. Thanks, -Manish Goregaokar On Wed, May 10, 2017 at 5:14 PM, Manish Goregaokar <manishsm...@gmail.com> wrote: > So I took a try push with all expectations set as passing and went about > categorizing the reftest failures. > > I'm halfway done. This is pre-HasAuthorSpecifiedRules and there are lots > of related failures. At some point I'll extract all the HASR-marked > failures and have a second look at the ones which are still not passing > after the HASR bug lands. > > https://gist.github.com/Manishearth/086118c940ff86a6cfc573f53c508279 > > While I've investigated many of these, many others still don't have well > known reasons. > > It would be quite helpful if everyone could help investigate. Ctrl-F > "unknown" on that page, anything with "unknown" in the explanation needs > more investigation. > > If you do file bugs (or find existing bugs), please let me know so that I > can update the page. I haven't yet had time to really file bugs for each > failure, and I intend to do this once done with the rest, but help now > would be appreciated! > > There are also some possibly-low-hanging-fruit failures where I've > investigated the reason and mentioned it, but not yet filed an issue. > > I'll continue to push more reftest failure categorizations as I get > through, and I intend to write some scripts that let me keep this doc > somewhat up to date as major groups of failures get fixed. > > Thanks, > -Manish Goregaokar > _______________________________________________ dev-servo mailing list dev-servo@lists.mozilla.org https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-servo
