Hi Christopher,
On 2025/3/22 09:58, Christopher Obbard wrote:
Hi Vagrant and Kever,
On Tue, 18 Mar 2025, 18:22 Vagrant Cascadian, <vagr...@debian.org> wrote:
On 2023-08-31, Christopher Obbard wrote:
> Package name : rkbin
> Version : 0.0.0~git20230726.b4558da
> Upstream Contact: Kever Yang <kever.y...@rock-chips.com>
> URL : https://github.com/rockchip-linux/rkbin
> License : Copyright © 2017-2023，Rockchip Electronics Co.,
> Ltd. All rights reserved.
> Programming Lang: n/a; prebuilt firmware binaries
> Description : Pre-built Rockchip bootloader firmware
binaries (for embedded targets)
>
> This package contains the Rockchip bootloader firmware binaries,
primarily
> used for targets where no open-source versions is yet released.
> The pre-built firmware consists of builds of Arm Trusted
Firmware, OP-TEE
> and U-Boot. There are also some closed-source tools in this
repo, build for
> amd64. These will be stripped from the upstream source package
as I do
> not (yet) see a need for these.
> This package is required to build U-Boot for some embedded
targets such as
> rk3588, rk3566, rk3568. All of these will eventually have
open-source
> firmware, but it is still useful for new processors in the
future where
> U-Boot support will be merged long before the initial DRAM
bringup and
> trusted firmware.
Arm Trusted Firmware for some of these rk35xx variants is now
supported
in the Debian packaging and upstream. I think the only thing left for
rk3588 is the DDR training binaries from rkbin:
https://www.collabora.com/news-and-blog/blog/2024/02/21/almost-a-fully-open-source-boot-chain-for-rockchips-rk3588/
Not sure about the other rk35xx variants.
@Kever I wonder if rockchip plan to open source the RAM training into
u-boot like other platforms?
I have check internally for this topic, there is no plan for open source
the ddr init binary recently for rk35xx SoCs.
Rockchip already provide the source based ddrbin_tool to modify the ddr
binary with all the possible
parameter which may need by customers.
So it would be better for the rkbin can merge into the Debian
non-free-firmware package.
Thanks,
- Kever
This would remove need for rbkin in Debian.
PS: I don't have time to look at packaging robin until the late
summer. If someone else wishes to do it, I'd happily help with
reviewing and sponsor an upload into Debian.
Chris
> I expect this package will go into non-free-firmware.
I *think* this license looks plausible for non-free-firmware:
https://github.com/rockchip-linux/rkbin/blob/master/LICENSE
Rockchip hereby grants to you a non-exclusive license (a) to
use, copy,
distribute the Software; (b) to modify any source code as part
of Software(if
any) and sublicense, distribute such modifications.
Except as expressively authorized by Rockchip in writing, you
may NOT:
(a) decompile, reverse-engineer, dissemble, or attempt to derive
any source
code from the Software;
(b) remove or obscure any copyright, patent, or trademark
statement or notices
contained in the Software.
Those exclusions might make it hard for folks to come up with free
implementations, though. :(
live well,
vagrant
