On Sat, Mar 13, 2021 at 06:42:01PM -0500, Stefan Monnier wrote: > >> > I'll stick with Signal for now, at least it's something that I can > >> > confidently recommend to people as "WhatsApp, but really > >> > secure/private". > >> I guess it's a bit more secure/private than whatsapp because you can see > >> the code of the client, but AFAICT it's still just as centralized :-( > > Since it's end-to-end encrypted I fail to see what major benefit > > federation would bring for one-to-one communication and small private > > groups. > > WhatsApp is also (presumably!) end-to-end encrypted, so that's not the > only problem with it. > > The problem is also the metadata: it still leaves a centralized record > of who sent what size of message to whom at what time and from which > IP address.
It's definitely more than just "dry" IP addresses: "In January 2021, WhatsApp announced update to Privacy Policy which states that WhatsApp will share user data with Facebook and its "family of companies" starting February 2021. Previously, users could opt-out of such data sharing, but the new policy removes this option. The new Privacy Policy does not apply within EU, since it is illegal under GDPR." [1] Come on. Facebook shelled out short of 20 *billion* for Whatsapp in 2014. Don't tell me it was just philantropy. For Mark Zuckerberg's private hobby it's a tad too expensive -- the investors want to see return. Some more juicy "user data" than just boring IP addresses (esp. in times where the IPv6 is kind-of randomised anyway) must be in for that deal. > Hopefully they throw this information away ASAP, but I have no reason to > presume that they do (e.g. even if they do intend to, someone hacking their > server could collect that information without their knowledge). Throw away? At most they let it lying around on some cloud, but I think FB can afford the pros to not botch it up so blatantly. Smaller start-ups, though... Cheers [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whatsapp#Security_and_privacy - t
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
