[not responding to the OP, I think he's already gotten an answer. this is for people reading the archive.]

The filesystem UUID is written into the filesystem when it is created. It's possible (though not necessarily easy) to change using tune2fs and other specialized filesystem tools. It does not "just change". It is also possible to write a label, or name, on the filesystem. It is written into the filesystem right next to the UUID. There are a couple of exceptions: FAT filesystems don't support a true UUID, for example. There are also partition UUIDs, the details for which depend on the partition table type. So why use UUIDs? In the old days we just used drive letters to identify filesystem locations, something like sda1 or hda1, and these rarely changed because they were associated with disk controllers with static cabling. (Although it was a bit of a pain to add or remove a controller.) On a modern system, though, it's actually not at all uncommon for drive letter assignments to change depending on what's plugged in at boot time, because of USB and other dynamic bus attachments. In practice, using UUIDs for filesystem assignments has been more reliable than relying on drive letters for quite a while. It's also possible to use filesystem labels, but in practice it turned out to be not uncommon for two different systems to have something like "root", which caused a lot of trouble when you put a drive from one system into another system. You could give the labels unique random names, but then you've (re)invented the UUID.

I understand that some people are saying that "something happened" and years ago they had a UUID change, but that's not really much to help diagnose a problem. In general it would be bad advice for people to assume there's a real problem and abandon UUIDs based on hearsay. If someone has a current case where they think a UUID is changing it would be useful to bring it up here so we could see exactly which ID they're talking about and try to diagnose what's going on. (It's probably not the case that the filesystem UUID is just randomly changing.)

For the curious, you can run "blkid" to see all of the IDs associated with your filesystems.

Mike Stone

Reply via email to