On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 04:53:28PM +0530, Arvind Marathe wrote: > > Hi! > > As mentioned in another thread yesterday, i have setup getmail to > retrieve mails from my gmail id. In my setup, getmail delivers the > mail to procmail, which in turn filters them into different mailboxes, > including a "possible-spam" mailbox depending on certain criteria. Now > all my d-u mails are getting filtered as spam. Following are the rules > in my $HOME/.procmailrc: > > > :0 > * ^X-Spam-Status: Yes > possible-spam/ > # > :0 > * ^X-Spam-Level: ***** > possible-spam/ > # > :0 > * ^X-Spam-Flag:.*YES > possible-spam/ > > > > And following are some lines from $HOME/.procmaillog: > > > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 09:50:27 2008 > Subject: Re: What is ~~ into inittab? > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217132427.27009_0.laasya 6758 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 10:25:21 2008 > Subject: Wi-Fi in Inspiron 1720 - Help! > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217134521.27203_0.laasya 4602 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 11:05:31 2008 > Subject: Re: [OT] Setting up getmail to retrieve mails from gmail [Was: Re: > Folder: debian-users/new/1217136931.27423_1.laasya 4568 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 11:20:17 2008 > Subject: Re: [OT] Setting up getmail to retrieve mails from gmail [Was: Re: > Folder: debian-users/new/1217137817.27513_1.laasya 4556 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 12:40:24 2008 > Subject: [OT] Turion 64X2 desktop? > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217142624.27958_0.laasya 5045 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 14:05:21 2008 > Subject: Re: [OT perhaps] Any way to restore Iceweasel 2 behavior in the > Navig > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217147721.28424_0.laasya 5300 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 14:30:23 2008 > Subject: How do I update kernel in Debian 4 > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217149223.28563_0.laasya 5741 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 14:50:30 2008 > Subject: Re: [OT perhaps] Any way to restore Iceweasel 2 behavior in the > Navig > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217150430.28673_0.laasya 5456 > >From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Jul 27 15:45:47 2008 > Subject: Re: [OT perhaps] Any way to restore Iceweasel 2 behavior in the > Folder: possible-spam/new/1217153747.29188_0.laasya 4989 > > > As you can see, only Andrei Popescu's mails, which also had a 'cc' to > my email address, get delivered to the proper mailbox. All other mails > to d-u get filtered as spam. Also Andrei's mails do not have the > mailing list headers whereas the other mails had. So i am assuming > Andrei's mails reached me directly and his mails via d-u were thrown > out by gmail. > > I am also subscribed to some other mailing lists, and those mails are > delivered to the appropriate mailboxes by procmail. (For eg., mutt > mailing list mails are delivered as desired). > > About a year back, i was subscribed to d-u for a short time from my > workplace account. The filter settings were same, and those mails were > not labelled as spam. So this might have something to do with gmail. I > don't have much experience with this kind of settings, so any pointers > as to why this must be happening are appreciated.
OK some more investigation. All the d-u mails, getting listed as spam, have X-Spam-Checker-Version, X-Spam-Level and X-Spam-Status, in their headers. For eg. one of the mails has: X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 3.2.3 (2007-08-08) on liszt.debian.org X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=0.1 required=4.0 tests=MDO_DATING2 autolearn=no version=3.2.3 Andrei's mails and the mutt mailing list mails do not have these headers. Arvind -- Quidquid latine dictum sit, altum sonatur. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
