Thanks for responding.  Responses (rationalizations?) are in relevant sections 
of your text.

Rob Heilman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Smart ass answer:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=Ama_XmSA8wflqkjrwiMowZAjzKIX?qid=1006031517403

Seriously, many people have already responded to this thread.  Many have 
made suggestions despite a lack of information from you:  "apt-get 
install k3b", "apt-get install supsys", "try Ubuntu", etc.  I agree that 
if you are having issues with Debian try an easier distro.  I 
particularly like to put new people on Kubuntu.  (Insert Gnome/KDE 
debate here.)  Personally I think KDE is an easier transition for long 
time Windows users.

In you defense print and sound issues can be a real pain.  This however 
is the usually more of a driver problem than OS problem.  Many of the 
hardware manufactures do no release Linux drivers for their hardware.  
This is starting to change, but slowly.  In the mean time people in 
their own free time are developing drivers usually without even the 
slightest manufactuer specifications from which to work.  The fact that 
they get these devices to work is quite amazing.  

Actually I know the pain-reward cycle well.  In the early days of WordPerfect I 
got it to do a few things that I needed in spite of the fact that Orem, Utah 
(the original home of WP) told me it couldn't do them.

Additionally, many 
printer manufacturers simply slap the same internal parts into a 
different chassis, speed up some mechanical units, and call it a new 
model (cough HP cough.)  Similar things happen in the sound world.  For 
this reason you have to do a little reading to figure out which driver 
you need to use.  This is not dissimilar to finding the right driver in 
Windows.

I am guessing that this was not a serious attempt by you to get help, 
but rather a rant / vent session.  If this was a serious attempt at 
getting help you need to learn a few things about how to ask for help.  
Humbly saying "please help me" and "why doesn't this crap work" are two 
completely different approaches to requesting assistance.  Further more 
saying "printing is  broke" and "I can not get my HP 2170 to print 
properly in Debian Etch via CUPS" are quite different. 

Actually you are right and wrong at the same time.  When I took writing 
training I was told that the first thing to do was get everything down and 
clean it up later.  Unfortunately I was very tired and hit the wrong key 
sequence that sent it instead of stored it.  I am awake now and twice in the 
last ten minutes have I hit the wrong sequence.  Shift and Control are 
transposed.  I'll get used to it.  As a novice writer, among other things, I am 
used to writing and then re-writing many times until it says exactly what I 
want it to say.  As an example, were I ever to write "printing is broken", to 
use your example, I would then add "how do I fix it?"


Do you really get legitimate help from saying "My damn printer does not 
work in Windows?"  I bet not.  People will want to know; printer model, 
parallel or USB, Windows Shared or TCP/IP direct, Windows Version

I have been quite frustrated before with Linux, but I have also been 
just as frustrated with Solaris, HPUX, IRIX, BSD, OSX, and the beloved 
Windows.  To vent your frustration in a "Linux sucks.  It is only a 
partial OS."  is not only counter productive but also shows a lack of 
understanding regarding the definition of an Operating System.

-D

S C wrote:
> For months now I have been trying to make Debian behave like a real 
> OS.  However, I still cannot print, format/initialize a new cd or use 
> one to back up files, get the sound working, watch a movie or read 
> images from my digital camera.  With Windows all this was simple.  I 
> downloaded the relevant program, set it up and it worked.  Windows is 
> supposed to be devilspawn and doomed, and maybe it is.  It does, 
> however, have one saving grace; it works.  It works without expecting 
> me to become a systems engineer.
>
> When I go to someplace like freenode/#debian I am ignored.  Maybe I 
> should say to Hell with Linux and sell my story to Microsoft.  
> Obviously I don't really want to, but how much longer should I put up 
> with a partial OS?  I don't mind telling you I'm damned sick of it.
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Ask a question on any topic and get answers from real people. *Go to 
> Yahoo! Answers.*  



       
---------------------------------
Be smarter than spam. See how smart SpamGuard is at giving junk email the boot 
with the All-new Yahoo! Mail  

Reply via email to