severity 407519 important
thanks

On Fri, 19 Jan 2007, Marc Fargas wrote:
> severity critical
> tags +patch
> thanks
> 
> The current Django versión in Debian has a security hole, so this bug 
> should be critical, and the patch recommended by the submitter should be
> applied and brought to etch, I think.

If I understand the bug correctly, the filename of the .po must be
modified to include commands with backticks... in other word, the
malicious intent is easily recognisable.

I expect that in 99,9% of the time, the person starting compile-messages
just copied/installed the .po files where required... and he certainly
would notice that the filename look very strange compared to the other
files !

So I really don't agree with severity critical... which brings to the
point that you shouldn't change the severity without justifying your
statement. "has a security hole" is a bit short without explaining a
likely case of security breach. In particular, when upstream has not
considered the risk serious enough to warrant a point release...

Of course, I'd like to hear opinions from others.

Regards,
-- 
Raphaël Hertzog

Premier livre français sur Debian GNU/Linux :
http://www.ouaza.com/livre/admin-debian/

Reply via email to