to 12.12.2024 klo 18.30 Paul Gevers (elb...@debian.org) kirjoitti: > On 11-12-2024 14:34, Daniel Gröber wrote: > > Martin and me are having a disagreement on what constitutes an RC bug. I > > was wondering if you could give us your view of the matter. Since I'm not > > sure you usually deal with these sorts of things "Go ask TC" is ofc. a > > perfectly valid response I just thought perhaps we're not quite at that > > stage yet. > > We are explicitly delegated to decide what issues are RC [1].
Looking forward to the decision. > > Context: dhcpcd-base has taken over DHCP duties from isc-dhcp-client in > > ustable via priority override at Martin's request. This changes a Debian > > installs DHCP behaviour in a number of ways which I think will cause people > > problems when they upgrade to trixie, this is one of them. > > We do have Release Notes to (also) document important changes like this. >From the Release Notes' perspective, the only meaningful change that dhcpcd-base brings is that, in most cases, a separate inet6 stanza won't be required in /etc/network/interfaces since both IPv4 and IPv6 stacks are handled by the same binary. dhcpcd-base's README.Debian tells more. I don't think that not advertising the hostname and thus not implementing DDNS by default is a significant change. The release team is of course welcome to document it. Alternately, if the release team thinks that DDNS should work out of the box, this can be enforced using the --hostname option in the ifupdown command line. Martin-Éric
