Hi Bastien,

Could you have a look at this bug (in particular) the mail below.

The bug has been tagged buster-ignore, but we would still like a more
user-friendly solution (even if just in the form of a NEWS entry, so
upgrading people are not caught unaware).

Thanks,
~Niels

On Sun, 7 Apr 2019 09:33:34 +0200 Wolfgang Silbermayr
<wolfg...@silbermayr.at> wrote:
> Having been hit by this on Buseter Testing before, I did some
> investigation. Here are my findings:
> 
> Conditions for this bug to appear are:
> 
>    * timidity-daemon is installed
>    * timidity service (from the timidity-daemon package) is enabled or
>      timidity gets started by hand
>    * No midi device is provided by the kernel
> 
> Only if all of these these conditions are fulfilled at the same time,
> this comes into effect.
> 
> A quick test on Stretch with the timidity service enabled did not reveal
> the bug. However, timidity was not running after boot, and I didn't find
> the reason why. After starting it by hand, pulseaudio got unusable, just
> like it does on Buster. So my guess is that the bug was actually present
> in Stretch, it just did not show due to timidity not starting properly
> at boot.
> 
> A removal of timidity-daemon on affected systems is sufficient. It is
> set to "Suggests" instead of "Recommends" with timidity as of 2.14.0-8,
> so the majority of people who install games or music programs that pull
> in timidity will no longer be affected.
> 
> People who will be affected are those that got timidity-daemon installed
> in Stretch by the "Recommends" dep, and then upgraded to Buster. Even an
> apt autoremove will keep timidity-daemon installed.
> 
> One way to escape this bug is to have a midi device available in the
> system, which can also be snd_virmidi. But I don't consider this a clean
> solution, because it will probably interfere for people who have real
> midi hardware.
> 
> What other options do we have? Simply keep it as-is and document it in
> the the upgrade manual? Or do we have some mechanism available that
> would remove timidity-daemon if it was installed automatically? Any
> other ideas?
> 
> 

Reply via email to