Hi,
On 2017-04-22 19:51, Paul Gevers wrote:
> On 22-04-17 00:26, Cobra wrote:
>> The directories are different when starting at boot:
> This doesn't sound good. I think it shouldn't matter how you call an
> init-script, it should behave the same. I guess this is speechd-up's
> responsibility.
>> At this stage, I think all these problems belong to speech-dispatcher.
> Well, I am not 100% convinced. The directory for the socket apparently
> comes from the environment, and I would say that that is the
> responsibility of the caller (in this case speechd-up or its init-script).
Might need some further testing, but imho that is speech-dispatcher's
problem, especially with the autospawn. I'd rather have
speech-dispatcher handle this correctly for all clients than make all
clients do the right thing (which they will inevitably fail to do).
Also, at the moment I think this happens only when not using systemd to
manage services. Still a bug though, especially because debian does
support other init systems.
>> That's a dead-end, speechd-up doesn't seem to be the primary culprit.
> Agree. But I wonder if for the issue at hand (installation failing due
> to init script failing) we should rather give up on providing an init
> script that works in all circumstances for now. It seems it may rely on
> configuration of speech-dispatcher (and sound). So maybe it is best for
> now to just disable the init script (in a similar way as for
> speech-dispatcher)?
Sounds like making this package quite useless and I think it's not
necessary. Fixing init script bugs should suffice.
> If not, thant I propose to clone this bug for speech-dispatcher.
> Cloning, because I think that the delta in socket path is something that
> speechd-up should fix. But that is probably (if it does not actually
> cause this issue) not RC. But than what would be the issue for
> speech-dispatcher? "speech-dispatcher doesn't work with pulse-audio when
> started from init-script"? That doesn't sound like a great thing.
I was thinking of reassigning to the current speech-dispatcher version
as "breaks with pulse output when spawned by speechd-up from init
system", keeping the RC level. Does this count as "breaking unrelated
packages"? I think so, but speechd-up and speech-dispatcher aren't
completely unrelated, so I'm unsure.
Without further input, I won't issue such bug control commands.
I'd rather open new bugs for any issues with speechd-up's init scripts
we find instead of cloning.
Like I announced, I did some further testing, but with a fresh debian
install now - the same base I used at the beginning, with systemd.
I can install speechd-up without any problem when I remove the
pulseaudio package, stop any running pa daemons, and configure
speech-dispatcher to use alsa instead before running apt install.
The installation succeeds without any warning, speechd-up is running
afterwards.
$ systemctl status speechd-up.service
● speechd-up.service - LSB: Interface between speakup and speech-dispatcher
Loaded: loaded (/etc/init.d/speechd-up; generated; vendor preset: enabled)
Active: active (running) since Sat 2017-04-22 20:40:19 CEST; 23s ago
Docs: man:systemd-sysv-generator(8)
CGroup: /system.slice/speechd-up.service
├─2267 /usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
├─2270 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
├─2272 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
├─2274 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
└─2278 /usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method
unix_socket --socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
$ ps aux | grep "speec\h"
root 2267 0.0 0.1 105616 2696 ? Ssl 20:40 0:00
/usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
root 2270 0.0 0.1 59776 4504 ? SLl 20:40 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
root 2272 0.0 0.1 59788 4540 ? SLl 20:40 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
root 2274 0.0 0.3 142088 8580 ? SLl 20:40 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
root 2278 0.0 0.0 183144 2168 ? Ssl 20:40 0:00
/usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method unix_socket
--socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
I then stopped speechd-up with systemctl and waited for
speech-dispatcher to terminate (as expected).
$ sudo systemctl start speechd-up.service
$ systemctl status speechd-up.service
● speechd-up.service - LSB: Interface between speakup and speech-dispatcher
Loaded: loaded (/etc/init.d/speechd-up; generated; vendor preset: enabled)
Active: active (running) since Sat 2017-04-22 20:51:21 CEST; 1min 22s ago
Docs: man:systemd-sysv-generator(8)
Process: 2335 ExecStop=/etc/init.d/speechd-up stop (code=exited,
status=0/SUCCESS)
Process: 2375 ExecStart=/etc/init.d/speechd-up start (code=exited,
status=0/SUCCESS)
Tasks: 13 (limit: 4915)
CGroup: /system.slice/speechd-up.service
├─2387 /usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
├─2391 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
├─2393 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
├─2397 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
└─2404 /usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method
unix_socket --socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
$ ps aux | grep "speec\h"
root 2387 0.0 0.1 105616 2896 ? Ssl 20:51 0:00
/usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
root 2391 0.0 0.1 59776 4528 ? SLl 20:51 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
root 2393 0.0 0.1 59788 4664 ? SLl 20:51 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
root 2397 0.1 0.3 142088 8536 ? SLl 20:51 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
root 2404 0.0 0.0 183144 2284 ? Ssl 20:51 0:00
/usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method unix_socket
--socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
Rebooting the system.
$ systemctl status speechd-up.service
● speechd-up.service - LSB: Interface between speakup and speech-dispatcher
Loaded: loaded (/etc/init.d/speechd-up; generated; vendor preset: enabled)
Active: active (running) since Sat 2017-04-22 21:00:22 CEST; 24s ago
Docs: man:systemd-sysv-generator(8)
Tasks: 13 (limit: 4915)
CGroup: /system.slice/speechd-up.service
├─518 /usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
├─530 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
├─544 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
├─551 /usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
└─589 /usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method
unix_socket --socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
$ ps aux | grep "speec\h"
root 518 0.0 0.1 105616 2740 ? Ssl 21:00 0:00
/usr/bin/speechd-up -l1
root 530 0.1 0.1 59776 4496 ? SLl 21:00 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_dummy
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/dummy.conf
root 544 0.1 0.1 59788 4592 ? SLl 21:00 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_generic
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/generic.conf
root 551 0.5 0.3 142088 8420 ? SLl 21:00 0:00
/usr/lib/speech-dispatcher-modules/sd_espeak-ng
/etc/speech-dispatcher/modules/espeak-ng.conf
root 589 0.0 0.0 183144 2300 ? Ssl 21:00 0:00
/usr/bin/speech-dispatcher --spawn --communication-method unix_socket
--socket-path /root/.cache/speech-dispatcher/speechd.sock
Yep, things are really working without pulseaudio and there aren't any
directory changes with systemd handling things. Logs are also there.
speechd-up is only breaking when speech-dispatcher is configured in a
special way, but sadly it's speech-dispatcher's default config.
