Your message dated Sat, 19 Nov 2011 20:42:50 -0800
with message-id <20111120044250.ga9...@icarus.andrew.net.au>
has caused the report #645760,
regarding Source package contains non-free IETF RFC/I-D
to be marked as having been forwarded to the upstream software
author(s) dhcp-b...@isc.org
(NB: If you are a system administrator and have no idea what this
message is talking about, this may indicate a serious mail system
misconfiguration somewhere. Please contact ow...@bugs.debian.org
immediately.)
--
645760: http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=645760
Debian Bug Tracking System
Contact ow...@bugs.debian.org with problems
--- Begin Message ---
Hi,
Could you please remove the RFCs from the embedded BIND sources in the DHCP
sources? As they're non-free, this makes DHCP non-free from Debian's
perspective, which royally complicates things.
Please maintain the Cc of this email to keep our bug tracking system in the
loop.
regards
Andrew
----- Forwarded message from Simon Josefsson <si...@josefsson.org> -----
Date: Tue, 18 Oct 2011 14:24:57 +0200
From: Simon Josefsson <si...@josefsson.org>
To: sub...@bugs.debian.org
Subject: Bug#645760: Source package contains non-free IETF RFC/I-D
Severity: serious
Package: isc-dhcp
Version: 4.2.2-1
User: debian-rele...@lists.debian.org
Usertags: nonfree-doc rfc
Hi!
This source package contains the following files from the
IETF under non-free license terms:
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/contrib/zkt/doc/rfc5011.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1032.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5011.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1033.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1034.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1035.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1101.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1122.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1123.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1183.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1348.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1535.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1536.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1537.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1591.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1611.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1612.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1706.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1712.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1750.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1876.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1886.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1912.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1982.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1995.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc1996.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2052.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2104.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2119.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2133.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2136.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2137.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2163.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2168.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2181.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2230.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2308.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2317.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2373.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2374.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2375.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2418.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2535.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2536.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2537.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2538.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2539.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2540.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2541.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2553.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2671.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2672.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2673.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2782.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2825.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2826.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2845.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2874.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2915.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2929.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2930.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc2931.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3007.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3008.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3071.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3090.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3110.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3123.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3152.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3197.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3225.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3226.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3258.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3363.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3364.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3425.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3445.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3467.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3490.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3491.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3492.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3493.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3513.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3596.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3597.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3645.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3655.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3658.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3755.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3757.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3833.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3845.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc3901.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4025.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4033.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4034.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4035.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4074.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4159.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4193.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4255.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4294.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4339.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4343.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4367.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4398.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4408.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4431.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4470.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4471.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4472.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4509.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4634.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4635.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4641.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4648.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4697.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4701.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4892.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4955.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc4956.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5001.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5155.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5205.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5452.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5507.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5625.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5702.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc5933.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/rfc/rfc952.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-6man-text-addr-representation-07.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-behave-address-format-07.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-behave-dns64-11.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-axfr-clarify-14.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-dns-tcp-requirements-03.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-dnssec-bis-updates-12.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-dnssec-registry-fixes-06.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-ecc-key-07.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-interop3597-02.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-rfc2671bis-edns0-02.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-rfc2672bis-dname-19.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-rfc3597-bis-02.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsext-tsig-md5-deprecated-03.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-bad-dns-res-05.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-default-local-zones-10.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-key-timing-00.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-trust-history-01.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-inaddr-required-07.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-respsize-06.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-ietf-dnsop-name-server-management-reqs-02.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-kato-dnsop-local-zones-00.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-kerr-ixfr-only-01.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-mekking-dnsop-auto-cpsync-00.txt
dhcp-4.2.2/bind/bind.tar.gz:bind-9.8.0-P4/doc/draft/draft-yao-dnsext-bname-04.txt
The license on RFC/I-Ds is not DFSG-free, see:
* http://bugs.debian.org/199810
* http://release.debian.org/removing-non-free-documentation
* http://wiki.debian.org/NonFreeIETFDocuments
According to the squeeze/wheezy release policy, source packages must be
DFSG-free, see:
* http://release.debian.org/squeeze/rc_policy.txt
* http://release.debian.org/wheezy/rc_policy.txt
The severity is serious, because this violates the Debian policy:
* http://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ch-archive.html#s-dfsg
There are (at least) three ways to fix this problem. In order of
preference:
1. Ask the author of the RFC to re-license the RFC under a free
license. A template for this e-mail request can be found at
http://wiki.debian.org/NonFreeIETFDocuments
2. Remove the non-free material from the source, e.g., by re-packaging
the upstream archive and adding 'dfsg' to the Debian package
version name.
3. Move the package to non-free.
General discussions are kindly requested to take place on debian-legal
or debian-devel in the thread with Subject: "Non-free IETF RFC/I-Ds in
source packages".
Thanks,
Simon
----- End forwarded message -----
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
--- End Message ---
