Package: perspic-texts
Version: 1.5-5.1
Severity: serious
Justification: Policy 4.5, 2.3

debian/copyright states only that the package is GPL.

perspic-texts is 16MB of compressed data, in a format for reading by Perspic.
If I understand correctly, the data is a derivative work.

>From README.texts:
    Perspic supplies several pre-indexed and compressed binary archives of
    texts freely available on the Internet from various locations.  As a
    text searching and word reference program, perspic supplies to the
    user only excerpts from these texts.  The full versions of the
    original documents cannot be retrieved without significant alterations
    to the program itself.  Should a user of perspic do so, he or she
    should be aware that these documents often come with their own
    copyright statements, which are binding on the end user.  As certain
    of these are supplied separately from the texts themselves, they are
    included here for reference.

The last sentence suggests that there are copyright statements within the data
that aren't reproduced outside the binary blob.  Bug #511199 prevents me from
looking at the compressed data.

They're in blob form in the package-source too (and the filenames start with a 
'.').

In addition to the religious texts (which I'd guess would be mainly
public-domain), there's a thesaurus, and something about translations.


The copyright statement that is reproduced in README.texts is a no-sell license:
    These documents may not be sold for profit or
    incorporated in commercial documents without the written permission of the
    Baha'i International Community.
    ...
    Permission is expressly granted for these documents to be made available
    for file transfer from installations offering unrestricted anonymous file
    transfer on the Internet.  These documents are provided as is without any
    express or implied warranty. Permission for re-use of these documents in
    "value-added" or "for profit"  re-publications (in print or electronic
    formats), may be requested from: ...



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-rc-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to