clone 440007 -1 retitle -1 cl-irc: Debian changelog doesn't reflect uploaded versions notfound -1 20060514-dfsg-1 notfixed -1 20070905-dfsg-1 found -1 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1 thanks
Hi Ben! I cloned this bug since the Debian changelog mess has nothing to do with the original bug. Please check the new bug number before replying. On Wed, 16 Apr 2008 03:59:32 +0200, Ben Hutchings wrote: > Bug #440007 isn't known to be fixed in 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1 because it was > originally fixed in version 20070905-dfsg-1 and the current version is > not based on that. Version 20070905-dfsg-1 clearly enters unstable [1], but it seems that during the migration of the Debian VCS from darcs to git Peter forgot it was using darcs and instead imported the old bzr repository [2]. This led to your problem. Actually, the Debian changelog for version 20070905-dfsg-1 records to not-uploaded versions (20070315-dfsg-1 and 20070430-dfsg-1), since there's no mention of those into the Debain PTS or snapshot.d.n [3] and being version 20070106-dfsg-1 the previous one (but uploaded to experimental because of the etch freeze [4]). However, these two "stealth" versions are clearly present in the old darcs repository [5]. However, the Debian changelog for version 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1 completely misses the above four records and contains, instead, an unrelated version 20070504-dfsg-1, never uploaded. I guess this last version is present in the old bzr repository [6], but since I'm a bzr agnostic... I'd say that the best thing to do now would be to integrate the darcs missing versions (20070106-dfsg-1, 20070315-dfsg-1, 20070430-dfsg-1 and 20070905-dfsg-1) into the changelog for version 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1 and to remove the already present 20070504-dfsg-1. If we really want to be (quite) perfect, we can remove the unnecessary bits (Vcs-Bzr and usocket) from the 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1 changelog entry. Comments? I'll go with the solution above if no one replies in one week from now. > Has it been fixed? Yes, this for sure, even two times: 20070905-dfsg-1 and 1:0.8.1-dfsg-1! Thx, bye, Gismo / Luca Footnotes: [1] http://packages.qa.debian.org/c/cl-irc/news/20070917T190207Z.html [2] http://git.debian.org/?p=pkg-common-lisp/cl-irc.git;a=commitdiff;h=3ccbfb9a2fc4d4de54f68d3aa7de4a3d58a52b7f#patch8 [3] http://snapshot.debian.net/package/cl-irc [4] http://packages.qa.debian.org/c/cl-irc/news/20070206T133207Z.html [5] http://cl-debian.alioth.debian.org/repository/pvaneynd/cl-irc/ [6] http://cl-debian.alioth.debian.org/repository/pvaneynd/bzr-moved/cl-irc/
pgpeM3UA5d84l.pgp
Description: PGP signature
