On Thu, Feb 23, 2012 at 10:13 PM, Leo 'costela' Antunes
<cost...@debian.org> wrote:
> tag 661070 wontfix
> severity 661070 important
> --
>
> Hi,
>
> Sorry, but I disagree this is a bug.
Hi Leo, i think you misunderstand my misunderstanding. :-)
> On 24/02/12 00:45, Aurélio A. Heckert wrote:
>> When i installed transmission-daemon i think i could use
>> transmission-gtk as on of this interfaces what was worst
>> then a false idea.
>
> (...)
> So I believe it's pretty clear transmission-gtk and transmission-daemon
> aren't meant to be used together.
> Have you checked transmission-remote-gtk[0]? Might be what you're
> looking for.
> Unfortunately I still haven't gotten around to packaging it though...
Yeah. I understand this before sending the bug. That is part of the
history and (i think) may help the description or pack improvement.
(Or i may talk to much and confused this report. Sorry!)
>> transmission-gtk stop to work when i install transmission-daemon
>> and the transmission-daemon also does not works. The log only
>> says "could not connect to tracker", to all torrents. But
>> rtorrent works perfectly.
>
> This could be caused by using the same peer-port on both programs, but I
> haven't checked if the tracker connection also uses this port. Either
> way it should only impact one of them (the one started last), so if
> you're experiencing this on both simultaneously it may be something else
> entirely.
Yes! **That is the problem!** Both can't work together. (work on the same
machine with different torrent list and users)
I think on the port problem, like you, but must not be the problem, because
the first must work.
>> They also was using the same default port for the web
>> interface (what is not a bug), and there i see they
>> was managing a different list of torrents.
>
> Transmission-daemon runs as a dedicated system-user, so it seems
> impractical to implement a solution where both share the same downloads.
> I am however very open to suggestions on this point, so if you have an
> idea how to make this work in a sane fashion, just let me know!
Nop... :-/
> Since I believe this bug stemmed more from a misunderstanding of how
> transmission works than from the fact that the daemon and the gtk
> interface don't play well together, I'm tagging it as wontfix. I do
> however believe there might be a legitimate use-case for it, so if this
> is really what you wanted, just let me know and we can try to find the
> problem.
Well, i think the conflict is a serious problem. We have 2 options:
1 - Must be possible to they work on the same machine. So the
pack must be reviewed or a upstream bug must be solved.
2 - Wont work on this bug. So both packs must explicit conflict
preventing the user to install both on the same system.
> Cheers
Cheers!
> [0] http://code.google.com/p/transmission-remote-gtk/
The transmission-cli pack has the transmission-remote. ;-)
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
