Package: nis
Version: 3.17-31
Severity: wishlist

I would suggest that each NIS client(!) ignores system
UIDs and GIDs defined in NIS. Advantages:

- the definition of "system UID" and "system GID" is
  done on the host affected by this definition

- installing or removing system packages with their own
  system pseudo user (e.g. ntp, exim, dbus, cups, zabbix,
  etc.) produce the same result, regardless whether
  your local NIS server has some forgotten entry with
  the same user or group name.

- these system services become independent from NIS at
  boot time and run time, too

Usually the NIS server doesn't distribute "reserved" UIDs
and GIDs, of course, but especially for historic
installations this is not thoroughly defined. Good ol'
SunOS reserved only UID<100 and GID<100 for the system,
for example.

AFAICS the suggested new feature wouldn't affect the
NIS server. It could still distribute his "non-system"
subset of UIDs and GIDs, whatever that means to him.
But the NIS clients could be configured to ignore the
burden of the past, if necessary.


Just an idea, of course. Regards

Harri



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to