Thanks for the patch. It looks mostly ok, but I have a few concerns:

 * People may have built up high scores in their home directories and
might be annoyed to have those disappear. Perhaps it could use the
scores in the home directory if present, otherwise the shared one?
Unfortunately we can't import these on upgrade: iterating home
directories may be expensive (many users), impossible (encrypted home
dirs), and/or unsafe (maliciously crafted score files).

 * The patch exposes an existing bug: exit(1) happens if the score
file can't be written. Oops! This will now happen if the user is not
in the "games" group (quite likely). Should instead complain and/or
fall back to the home directory.

 * The above two points then mean that the only users using the shared
file will be those who were already in the games group before first
run. It would be nice if everyone else got some sort of hint that
shared scores were now possible, somehow. Nothing that gets in the way
and needs acknowledgement, but perhaps a line in the UI near the high
scores? "See /usr/share/doc/crack-attack/README.scores"... not sure.

Thanks,
-- 
Chris Boyle
http://chris.boyle.name/



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to