Hi again!

It seems to me that the current implementation of assigning IP numbers breaks 
Samba network browsing.

All other things being equal, I observe the following behavior: If an zeroconf 
IP is assigned additionally to the real IP, then smbtree only shows my own 
computer. If I don't assign a zeroconf IP (by saying FALLBACK=yes 
in /etc/default/zeroconf), then smbtree shows all computers on my LAN.

I assume that this is caused by my box becoming the local master browser of 
the subnet belonging to the zeroconf IP, thus effectively splitting the Samba 
workgroup over two subnets. See section 1.4.3 of 
http://www.oreilly.com/catalog/samba/chapter/book/ch01_04.html for details.

Since the current implementation of zeroconf breaks unrelated software, I 
think this qualifies as a bug rather than a wishlist item.

So please, when assigning the zeroconf IP leave the primary IP intact. While 
I'm not certain about this, having the primary IP show up in the output of 
the current implementation of ifconfig might be a good indication.

Regards,
   Georg

-- 
Georg Wittenburg
http://page.mi.fu-berlin.de/~wittenbu/

Attachment: pgpZC2SrT43ZF.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to