Package: systemimager
Version: 3.4.1-1
Severity: minor

The copyright file, states, in part:

| e2fsprogs was downloaded from http://download.sourceforge.net/e2fsprogs/
| and is available under the terms of the GNU General Public License with
| the following exception:
|
|       If the version string in the file version.h contains the
|       string "pre-", or "WIP" then this package must be distributed
|       in source form only.  You can give a copy of the binary for
|       e2fsck to help a friend recover his or her filesystem, as the
|       need arises.  However, "pre" or "WIP" indicates that this
|       release is under development, and available for ALPHA testing.
|       So for your protection as much as mine, I'd rather not have it
|       appear in a some distribution --- especially not a CD-ROM
|       distribution!

Comparing with e2fsprogs Debian package copyright file, it seems
that this is a *request*, rather than a legally-binding *requirement*.
And that's a relief, since otherwise it would be an additional restriction
with respect to the GPL...

Please rephrase the copyright file in order to make it clear that this
is only a request, and not an exception to the GPL.
You could just copy and paste the relevant part of e2fsprogs deb
copyright:

[Theodore Ts'o speaking]
| However, I request that if the version string in the file version.h
| contains the string "pre-", or "WIP" that this version of e2fsprogs be
| distributed in source form only.  Please feel free to give a copy of
| the e2fsck binary to help a friend recover his or her filesystem, as
| the need arises.  However, "pre" or "WIP" indicates that this release
| is under development, and available for ALPHA testing.  So for your
| protection as much as mine, I'd prefer that it not appear in a some
| distribution --- especially not a CD-ROM distribution!


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to