On 28.Jun 2005 - 13:02:06, Loïc Minier wrote: > Hi, > > On Tue, Jun 28, 2005, Andreas Pakulat wrote: > > > Does artsd work if you remove the patch, or are you just getting the > > > same warning as in the initial report? > > My fault, artsd has the same problems as in the initial report (no > > playing, but loads of warnings from gst). > > Yeah, of course, I thought you would downgrade gstreamer too, but > should have mentionned it!
Now I don't get anything but a segfault with the gst-launch-command and
artsdsink. However amarok using gstreamer and artsdsink works.
> To finish the debate: if you place yourself in a situation where artsd
> is working
Ok, downgraded libgstreamer0.8-0 to 0.8.9-2 and amarok plays perfectly
with artsdsink. But as noted above, gst-launch segfaults (in case you
don't remember: gst-launch-0.8 filesrc location=mp3file ! spider !
audioscale ! audioconvert ! artsdsink)
> and you build gst-plugins yourself (that is: downgrade
> gstreamer, rebuild gst-plugins with "debuild" -- ie no flags --), does
> artsd still works? (This first test proves that artsd can work when
> you build the package yourself.)
Using amarok this works with the old libgstreamer. gst-launch segfaults.
> If yes, can you rebuild gst-plugins
> in the same configuration (debuild, no flags) with the one-line patch?
> (This second test would prove that my patch does not degrade a working
> situation in a non-working one.)
This works too with amarok, not with gst-launch.
I then upgraded libgstreamer to the newest version (0.8.10-2) and
retried all 3 above, with the following result:
* libgstreamer-0.8.10-2+gstreamer0.8-artsd from unstable:
amarok broken, as in the initial report, gst-lauch broken as in the
initial report (no segfault anymore)
* libgstreamer-0.8.10-2+self-build gstreamer0.8-artsd:
both as above.
* libgstreamer-0.8.10-2+self-build gstreamer0.8-artsd+your patch:
gst-launch segfaults, amarok plays, as if I'd use the old
libgstreamer. Sorry for not trying amarok witht his combination
eralier (I just did rely on gst-launch)
So, from all the testing, what do we know:
1. Building gst-plugins myself is not causing trouble with amarok and
old libgstreamer
2. Building gst-plugins with your fix is not causing trouble with the
old libgstreamer and amarok
3. Using a new libgstreamer we have a problem with unstable and
self-built artsdsink in amarok and gst-launch
4. using a new libgstreamer and your fix we have a working amarok, but a
crashing gst-launch...
So I would guess, this particular bug is fixed with your patch and we
need to open a new one for gst-launch segfaulting with artsdsink...
Andreas
--
You need more time; and you probably always will.
pgpdLvIbovDBk.pgp
Description: PGP signature
