Hi Philipp 

Apologies for not following up earlier.

On Mon, 20 Oct 2008, Philipp Hübner wrote:
> I tried, it's definetly not needed.
> Furthermore I installed system-config-lvm and lvm2 on a clean
> lenny-system: dm_mod get's loaded instantly after the installation,
> system-config-lvm works out of the box.
>
> Then I removed all the dm_-modules manually, and tried again:
> system-config-lvm still came up, without problems.
> I checked, and after system-config-lvm had reloaded lvm2, the
> dm_-modules still weren't loaded.

I had a look at this.

I installed etch in virtualBox, then upgraded to lenny. The dm_-modules were 
loaded even before I installed system-config-lvm and lvm2.  So something is 
different between that vm and my desktop.  I've had a quick look and 
nothing stands out as obvious to me.  (And I probably won't get around to 
following that up).

> Haven't tried to use system-config-lvm then, as you already told me that
> without dm_mod lvcreate etc. don't work.
>
If I stop lvm and unload dm_mod, system-config-lvm crashes with the same 
stacktrace as the initial bug report.  If I try the same in the vm, 
system-config-lvm works ok.  It allows me to initialise partitions, add them 
to volume groups, but not to create logical volumes.  (When I attempt to 
create an lv it displays the same error message as lv-create in a message 
box, but doesn't crash).

So again there is something different between my Desktop originally 
installed pre-etch, and an more recent default install.

> So it seams, dm_mod has not caused your crash directly, which is gone
> now I assume?

Crash is gone, unless I manually unload dm_mod (which counts as user error).  
Agreed that dm_mod doesn't seem to be the cause of the crash, despite how I 
can trigger the crash on my desktop.  

Strange how my desktop and the vm differs.  Maybe after years of upgrades I 
should think about a clean install ;) .  Need to move 64-bit eventually.

>
> The bug you filed against lvm2 could be right though.
>
Will follow up with similar info there.

Thanks for your help.
Andrew V.




--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to