On Mon, 17 Dec 2007 19:50:30 -0800
Don Armstrong <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> ...The bit of text that you have an issue with is merely advisory, ...

   % dog 
"http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/pkgreport.cgi?pkg=%3f%3f%3f%3f;dist=unstable";  
| html2text | nl | head -n 9 | tail -n 6
     4  ****** Debian Bug report logs: Bugs in package ???? in unstable ******
     5  No maintainer for ????. Please do not report new bugs against this 
package.
     6  You might like to refer to the ???? package page, to the Package 
Tracking
     7  System, or to the source package ????'s bug page.
     8  There is no record of the ???? package, and no bugs have been filed 
against it.
     9  See the archived reports or archived and unarchived reports

No advisory there regarding the possible existence of packages.

> ...and may be useful in the case
> of packages where there isn't a package now in unstable, but there was
> a package by that name in oldstable (or even just stable).

Of course it's useful, but the fix I suggested would also keep that
desirable behavior.

> Keeping track of all of the possibly valid package names merely to
> avoid providing useless text seems kind of counter-productive, IMO.

Text like:

        "You might like to refer to the ???? package page"

...isn't "useless", it's misleading -- I know in the past I have gone
burrowing around thinking there was a package named 'fou', (instead of
'foo'), and may even have sent in a bad bug or two based on that
mistaken impression.

Compromise kludge, (with the reservation that I believe the best fix
would be to keep track of all package names past and present, and offer only
valid links):  print fuzzy info, and explain how it's fuzzy.  Example:

    ****** Debian Bug report logs: No such package in unstable ******
    There is no record of a Microsoft Windows Vista package.

    Note: while there is no package by that name in unstable, these URLs 
    to search stable and older Debian versions might help, if such a package
    ever existed.


HTH...



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to