On Tue, Sep 12, 2006 at 10:14:17AM +0100, Neil Williams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> was 
heard to say:
> >   In the create/edit account dialog, to make the account a toplevel
> > account, you select an item called "create new top-level account".  This
> > is correct for the "new account" dialog, but can lead to user confusion
> > in the "edit account" dialog (since they might think that selecting it
> > will somehow create a new account instead of editing the current
> > account).
> > 
> >   Daniel
> 
> This dialogue has changed in gnucash 2.0.1 (current Debian version is
> 2.0.1-2). When editing an existing account, the dialogue offers "New
> top-level account" as the highest placed parent. The dialogue layout has
> also changed.

  I don't see how this is an improvement over the previous behavior.

> In a real sense, setting an existing account as a top level account IS
> making a new top level account. If before there were five top level
> accounts (say Income, Expense, Assets, Liability and Equity) this change
> (on say Expense|Motor|Fuel) would make Fuel a sixth top level account.

  Yes, I know that, but I have a graduate degree in computer science.  I
filed this bug report after watching my mother struggle to edit her account
layout in Gnucash.

  I would suggest changing "New top-level account" to "Make this account
a top-level account" or even "Change this account to a top-level account",
to make it crystal-clear what it does.

  Daniel

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to