Control: tags -1 + help
* Bas Couwenberg <sebas...@xs4all.nl> [2021-08-19 21:13]:
Source: octave-mapping
Version: 1.4.1-1
Severity: important
Tags: ftbfs
User: debian-...@lists.debian.org
Usertags: gdal-3.3
Dear Maintainer,
Your package FTBFS with GDAL 3.3.1:
[inst/str2angle.m]
/build/octave-mapping-1.4.1/inst/str2angle.m
***** test
***** shared tst, res
tst = '191E21''3.1"\n12e 22''33.24"\n13E 23'' 33.344"\n14w24'' 33.4444"\n';
tst = [tst '15S25''33.54444"\n16W26''33.644444''''\n17s27''33.7444444"\n'];
tst = [tst '18N28''33.84444444"\n19d29m33.944444444s\n20D20M33.04444444Se\n'];
tst = [tst '21??51''4.1"\n22??52''44.25"\n23?? 53''33.34"\n24??54''
33.44"N\n'];
tst = [tst '25?? 55'' 33.544"\n26??56''33.644''''S\n27??57'' 33.744''''\n'];
tst = [tst '28??58''33.844"w'];
tst = strrep (tst, '\n', char(10));
res = [191.351, 12.376, 13.393, -14.409, -15.426, -16.443, -17.459, 18.476,
...
19.493, 20.343, 21.851, 22.879, 23.893, 24.909, 25.926, 26.943, ...
27.959, -28.976];
assert (str2angle (tst), res, 1e-3);
!!!!! test failed
ASSERT errors for: assert (str2angle (tst),res,1e-3)
Location | Observed | Expected | Reason
. O(1x1) E(1x18) Dimensions don't match
shared variables scalar structure containing the fields:
tst = [](0x0)
res = [](0x0)
***** test
tstc = strsplit (tst, "\n");
assert (str2angle (tstc), res, 1e-3);
!!!!! test failed
strsplit: S and DEL must be string values
shared variables scalar structure containing the fields:
tst = [](0x0)
res = [](0x0)
***** test
tstc = strjoin (strsplit (tst, "\n"), " ");
assert (str2angle (tstc), res, 1e-3);
!!!!! test failed
strsplit: S and DEL must be string values
shared variables scalar structure containing the fields:
tst = [](0x0)
res = [](0x0)
***** test
assert (str2angle ('24E77''33" 25W43''57.7"'), [NaN, -25.7333], 1e-3);
!!!!! test failed
ASSERT errors for: assert (str2angle ('24E77'33" 25W43'57.7"'),[NaN,
-25.7333],1e-3)
Location | Observed | Expected | Reason
. O(1x1) E(1x2) Dimensions don't match
shared variables scalar structure containing the fields:
tst = [](0x0)
res = [](0x0)
***** test
assert (str2angle ('; aggag'), Inf);
***** warning <inconvertible> str2angle ('24E77''33"', 1);
***** warning <inconvertible> str2angle (' -4D-32''-44.57"', 1);
***** error <char string or cellstr expected> str2angle (25);
8 tests, 5 passed, 0 known failure, 0 skipped
Thanks for this bug report.
This problem seems to be completely unrelated to the upgrade of the GDAL
library. The bug is exposed by the unit tests in the function str2angle,
defined in file inst/str2angle.m. This file contains purely Octave
interpreted code which is not related to libgdal.
I can replicate the bug on an up-to-date unstable chroot, without
libgdal28, ligdgal29, nor octave-mapping installed. When I run the
following commands in such a chroot:
sudo apt update
sudo apt dist-upgrade
sudo aptitude install octave
apt-get source octave-mapping
cd octave-mapping-1.4.1/inst
echo "test str2angle" | octave-cli --quiet
I obtain the following:
***** shared tst, res
tst = '191E21''3.1"\n12e 22''33.24"\n13E 23'' 33.344"\n14w24'' 33.4444"\n';
tst = [tst '15S25''33.54444"\n16W26''33.644444''''\n17s27''33.7444444"\n'];
tst = [tst '18N28''33.84444444"\n19d29m33.944444444s\n20D20M33.04444444Se\n'];
tst = [tst '21??51''4.1"\n22??52''44.25"\n23?? 53''33.34"\n24??54''
33.44"N\n'];
tst = [tst '25?? 55'' 33.544"\n26??56''33.644''''S\n27??57'' 33.744''''\n'];
tst = [tst '28??58''33.844"w'];
tst = strrep (tst, '\n', char(10));
res = [191.351, 12.376, 13.393, -14.409, -15.426, -16.443, -17.459, 18.476,
...
19.493, 20.343, 21.851, 22.879, 23.893, 24.909, 25.926, 26.943, ...
27.959, -28.976];
assert (str2angle (tst), res, 1e-3);
!!!!! test failed
ASSERT errors for: assert (str2angle (tst),res,1e-3)
Location | Observed | Expected | Reason
. O(1x1) E(1x18) Dimensions don't match
shared variables scalar structure containing the fields:
tst = [](0x0)
res = [](0x0)
Best,
Rafael Laboissière
P.S.1: I am hereby tagging this bug report "help", since I have no idea
where the problem comes from. It is probably due to a change in some of
the dependings libraries related to the upgrade from bullseye to
bookworm.
P.S.2: In order to not prevent the blocking of the ligdal 28→29
transition, we could transform the failing unit tests in str2angle.m from
"%!test" into "%!xtest". Subsequently, after the transition is done we
could try to fix the problem, which is independent of libgdal. What do
you think?
