control: reassign -1 libleveldb1d Quoting Matthew Gabeler-Lee (2019-08-28 03:16:45) > On Mon, 26 Aug 2019, Jonas Smedegaard wrote: > > > Quoting Matthew Gabeler-Lee (2019-08-26 15:42:32) > >> Given its a symbols related issue, arguably that package needs its > >> soversion bumped? > > > > If you mean bumping SOVERSION of bitcoin-qt, then I disagree, and ask > > you to please elaborate why you think that should be done. > > > > If you mean bumping SOVERSION of libleveldb1d then I agree. > > Yes, bumping soname/soversion of libleveldb is what I meant, sorry if > wording was unclear there. > > >> Indeed, this package needs its dependency on libleveldb1d bumped. > > > > This problem happened while there was no change to bitcoin-qt and while > > libleveldb1d was upgraded to a newer upstream version. > > > > The cause of this problem is therefore likely that libleveldb1d failed > > to bump its soname. Only if bitcoin-qt is linking beyond the public API > > of libleveldb1d is bitcoin-qt to blame for this failure. > > > > I see no need for bumping any dependencies: A simple rebuild made the > > package work again, which to me indicates that this is a bug in > > libleveldb1d. > > Again, unclear wording on my part, sorry. I didn't mean > bumping source dependency versions, just the binary version, > which rebuilding does. > > >> Given this makes the daemon not launch, it probably merits a severity > >> bump. > > > > Raising severity beyond "important" practically means "if this issue > > isn't fixed then better to remove the package from the arcive" which > > arguably doesn't make sense for bitcoin-qt (it works when only the right > > library is available) but certainly makes sense if reassigned to > > libleveldb1d (it is suspected that this issue affects other applications > > too). > > > > I have not had time to investigate closer if relevant to reassign, and > > prefer for now to leave this open but at non-fatal severity, as it is > > does not affect the 0.18.1~dfsg-1 release. > > I suspect that, whatever is done to libleveldb, a rebuild of the > bitcoin package will be required. > > > Help investigating closer would be much appreciated. > > apt-rdepends --reverse libleveldb1d gives: > > Reverse Depends: bitcoin-qt (0.18.1~dfsg-1) > Reverse Depends: bitcoind (0.18.1~dfsg-1) > Reverse Depends: caffe-tools-cpu (1.0.0+git20180821.99bd997-2+b1) > Reverse Depends: caffe-tools-cuda (1.0.0+git20180821.99bd997-4) > Reverse Depends: ceph-base (12.2.11+dfsg1-2.1) > Reverse Depends: ceph-mon (12.2.11+dfsg1-2.1) > Reverse Depends: ceph-osd (12.2.11+dfsg1-2.1) > Reverse Depends: ceph-test (12.2.11+dfsg1-2.1) > Reverse Depends: groestlcoin-qt (2.17.2~dfsg-1) > Reverse Depends: groestlcoind (2.17.2~dfsg-1) > Reverse Depends: libcaffe-cpu1 (1.0.0+git20180821.99bd997-2+b1) > Reverse Depends: libcaffe-cuda1 (1.0.0+git20180821.99bd997-4) > Reverse Depends: libleveldb-dev (= 1.22-3) > Reverse Depends: libleveldb1.2-cil (1.9.1-1.2) > Reverse Depends: libleveldb1d-dbgsym (= 1.20-2.1) > Reverse Depends: librime1 (1.4.0+dfsg1-2+b1) > Reverse Depends: litecoin-qt (0.17.1-1) > Reverse Depends: litecoind (0.17.1-1) > Reverse Depends: minetest (5.0.1+repack-2) > Reverse Depends: minetest-server (5.0.1+repack-2) > Reverse Depends: node-leveldown (1.5.0+dfsg-3+b1) > Reverse Depends: python-leveldb (0~svn68-3+b3) > Reverse Depends: python3-leveldb (0~svn68-3+b3) > Reverse Depends: stenographer (0.0~git20190528.0.6415e2b-1) > > Presumably this bug needs to be reassigned to libleveldb, and once fixed > there, bitcoin (and many other packages) will need to be rebuilt to > depend on the new binary package that generates (liblevedb1e?). > > Digging into the leveldb source and its differences between 1.20 and > 1.22, the "port" section of the library looks to have been completely > rewritten, so I think the first step here is to reassign this to leveldb > with a need for a soname bump since breaking changes were made to the > ABI there.
Thanks for the help. Hereby reassigned. - Jonas -- * Jonas Smedegaard - idealist & Internet-arkitekt * Tlf.: +45 40843136 Website: http://dr.jones.dk/ [x] quote me freely [ ] ask before reusing [ ] keep private
signature.asc
Description: signature
