Hi,

I was the one that originally proposed the update-smart-drivedb idea 
upstream (in 2010!).

  https://www.smartmontools.org/ticket/59

At the time I was trying to solve the problem of the drivedb getting out of 
date in debian releases very quickly and thus having to use backports or 
stable release updates to get it updated.

I now agree with Christoph that this is a risky thing to do. I think it 
should be enhanced to support authenticated copies of the database (GPG 
sigs? HSTS to a particular https site?). Until then I think it should be 
disabled or at least prompt the user to manually verify a checksum or 
something.

This bug can probably be forwarded upstream.

Thanks,

-- 
Matt Taggart
tagg...@debian.org

Reply via email to