Hi,

Thanks for very interesting bug report.

On Thu, Aug 16, 2012 at 04:38:39AM +0100, Ben Hutchings wrote:
> Package: debiandoc-sgml
> Version: 1.2.27
> Severity: important
> Tags: patch
> 
> In the kernel-handbook source we have:
> 
>     Check the <url 
> id="http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/pkgreport.cgi?src=linux&amp;src=linux-2.6"; 
> name="current bug list">

Yah, I kind of remember & ... in id-value was problematic.

debiandoc-sgml has some strange handling over special chars.

That was why I moved may documents to docbook and added deprecation note
to debiandoc-sgml.  There are not just this but many irregularities with
this software.

> And in the HTML output this becomes:
> 
>     Check the <code><a
>     
> href="http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/pkgreport.cgi?src=linux%5C%7C[amp%20]%5C%7Csrc=linux-2.6";>current
>     bug list</a></code>
> 
> I'm attaching a fix.  Please upload and ask for a freeze exception, as
> this causes real breakage in debian-kernel-handbook.

I give you 2 choices:

* Hijack this package and make whatever changes you wish ... but fully
  take over responsibility of maintenance.  (Please note this is what I
  am looking for.  You are certainly a good maintainer and you proved 
  this by your proposed patch.) 

* find some local hack in your package to work around this stupidity 
  and let me keep this package as is.  I would think a text like:

Check the <url id="http://bugs.debian.org/"; name="Debian Bug Tracking System"> 
while setting "Select bugs" section to "in source package" with "linux-2.6" as 
its entry data.

  (Unfortunately, I do not know what side effects your patch causes to
   other packages which assume this odd behavior.  Please understand.)

FYI: Have you read squeeze README.Debian of this package.

                         === NOTICE ===

The DebianDoc-SGML is becoming less used and its is not accepting any
new feature enhancements except localization data.

If you are creating a new documentation project or start making major
updates on the existing documents, please consider to use Docbook XML
system instead of DebianDoc-SGML because you will need things like
tables and figures which are not supported by this debiandoc-sgml
platform.

New direct conversion tool debiandoc2dbk in this package should provide
easy transition of existing debiandoc-sgml document contents into
DocBook XML format with minor manual interaction.

Since this is perl5/shell based script, it should run on squeeze without
any modification if texlive tools are installed.

                         ------------------

To be honest, I hated some internal SGML marking structure irregularities.  But
I did not wish to create non-compatible changes.  What you aim at with your
patch is certainly very good direction but clearly non-compatible change.  I do
not wish to such thing at this moment.

Please understand my position and why not step up to ***hijack***.
(I am willing to be sub-maintainer if you wish me to be around for this
package.)

Regards,

Osamu


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to