On Wed, 1 Mar 2017, John Levine wrote:
They're experiments. I'd think it'd be useful for the experiments to see whether salted or unsalted hashes work better (or worse.)
The experimental RFC for OPENPGPKEY is out already, and it does not support salting. So I don't know how you would experiment with that. If you are saying, since OPENPGPKEY uses unsalted, so let's pick salted for the SMIMEA experiment, I'd say that's unwise and goes against the wishes of the authors of both documents to use the same lookup method. It would also be mostly tested the operator, and no anything that goes over the wire, so it would be pretty subjective and non-statistical relevant. And I would predict the following outcome: Experiment with 1 zone: both work great! Experiment with many zones: Really happy using DNAME, so did not use salted. With fedorahosted.org, fedorapeople.org, fedoraproject.org, I was already in the latter category. Paul _______________________________________________ dane mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dane
