A Tuesday 08 March 2011 17:38:46 Sturla Molden escrigué: > But should we care if this is implemented with OpenMP or Python > threads? It's just an implementation detail in the library, not > visible to the user. > > Also I am not against OpenMP, I use it all the time in Fortran :-) > > Another problem with using OpenMP inside the compiler, as opposed to > an external library, is that it depends on a stabile ABI. If an ABI > change to Cython's generated C code is made, even a minor change, > OpenMP support will be broken.
And another problem that should be taken in account is that MS Visual Studio does not offer OpenMP in the Express edition (the free, as in beer, one). And, in addition, we can expect problems with the OpenMP support in GCC for Win. As I see this, if we could stick using just Python threads, that would be our best bet for having a good adoption of future Cython parallel capabilities. In the case that we need dealing with a low-level C-API thread library, I'd use pthreads, with a possible light wrapper for using it from the Windows thread API on Windows machines. -- Francesc Alted _______________________________________________ cython-devel mailing list cython-devel@python.org http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/cython-devel
