Hi Richard,

On 20.02.20 17:33, Richard Hughes wrote:
> I've tried many different .configs, and most of the data in the wiki
> and various blog posts is very old (multiple years) and as yet I
> haven't manage to build anything that boots, or even turns on the
> display for that matter.

there is little documentation but also little to do. This defconfig
should work:

CONFIG_USE_BLOBS=y
CONFIG_VENDOR_LENOVO=y
CONFIG_BOARD_LENOVO_X220=y

As mentioned already, the native raminit can be picky (it never failed
me on a T420, though). So with the blobed raminit, it should be most
stable:

# CONFIG_USE_NATIVE_RAMINIT is not set

Most common trouble comes from the flashing procedure, because the flash
chip is shared by multiple firmware components. It's best to have the
whole system in a known good state. Then, only flash the BIOS region
with coreboot (add `--ifd -i bios` to the flashrom command).

If all that doesn't help, the SPI flash console is much more useful
than spkrmodem (if one has an external flasher):

CONFIG_CONSOLE_SPI_FLASH=y

After running coreboot and dumping the flashchip, you can extract the
console with

  $ cbfstool coreboot-dump.rom read -r CONSOLE -f console.txt

(not 100% ASCII).

> Using spkmodem I am able to get some
> debugging output. Using CONFIG_USE_NATIVE_RAMINIT I get (ending in):
>
> SPD probe channel1, slot0
> Not a DDR3 SPD!
> No valid XMP profile found.
> Not a DDR3 SPD!
> SPD probe channel1, slot1JNot a DDR3 SPD!
> No valid XMP profile found.
> Not a DDR3 SPD!
> No DIMMs were found

I suppose spkmodem might be rather slow? This means coreboot failed to
read the DIMM's SPDs over the SMBus. This is actually very reliable...
but! There is a watchdog in the chipset that might kill the SMBus if it
times out. Long story short, if it takes longer than 4s to get there,
all bets are off.

Nico
_______________________________________________
coreboot mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to